The largest metallicity difference in twin systems: high-precision abundance analysis of the benchmark pair Krios & Kronos

P. Miquelarena,C. Saffe,M. Flores,R. Petrucci,J. Yana Galarza,J. Alacoria,M. Jaque Arancibia,E. Jofré,K. Montenegro Armijo,F. Gunella
2024-06-18
Abstract:Aims.We conduct a high-precision differential abundance analysis of the remarkable binary system HD 240429/30 (Krios and Kronos, respectively), whose difference in metallicity is one of the highest detected in systems with similar components to date (approximately 0.20 dex). A condensation temperature TC trend study was performed to search for possible chemical signatures of planet formation. In addition, other potential scenarios have been proposed to explain this disparity. Methods. Fundamental atmospheric parameters (Te f f , log g, [Fe/H], vturb) were calculated using the latest version of the FUNDPAR code employing high resolution MAROON-X spectra. We applied a full line-by-line differential technique to measure the abundances of 26 elements in both stars with equivalent widths and spectral synthesis taking advantage of the non-solar scaled opacities. Results.We found a difference in metallicity of approximately 0.230 dex, being Kronos more metal rich than Krios. The analysis encompassed the examination of the diffusion effect and primordial chemical differences, concluding that the observed chemical discrepancies in the binary system cannot be solely attributed to any of these processes. The results also shown a noticeable excess of Li by approximately 0.56 dex in Kronos, and an enhancement of refractories with respect to Krios. A photometric study with TESS data was carried out, without finding any signal of possible transiting planets around the stars. Several potential planet formation scenarios were also explored to account for the observed excess in both metallicity and lithium in Kronos. Planetary engulfment is a plausible explanation, considering the ingestion of an exceptionally large mass, approximately approximately 27.8M_Earth, but no scenario is definitively ruled out.
Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses the high-precision differential abundance analysis of the binary system Krios and Kronos (HD 240429/30), where the difference in metallicity between the two objects is the highest observed in similar systems so far (about 0.20 dex). The aim of the study is to understand this anomalous chemical difference, which challenges the basic assumption of chemical tagging techniques that stars born in the same cluster should have chemical consistency. The author calculated the fundamental atmospheric parameters of the stars, such as effective temperature, surface gravity, iron abundance, and microturbulence velocity, using high-resolution MAROON-X spectra. They measured the abundance of 26 elements in both stars using line-to-line differential techniques. They found that Kronos is about 0.230 dex more metal-rich than Krios, and Kronos also exhibits significantly higher lithium content, approximately 0.56 dex. Additionally, the study showed that refractory elements in Kronos are relatively increased compared to Krios. The study considered various possible explanations, including diffusion effects, primordial chemical differences, and the influence of planet formation. By studying the trend of condensation temperatures, they explored chemical signatures left by planet formation but did not find conclusive evidence. Although planet engulfment is a possible explanation, other possibilities, such as large planets formed early affecting dust distribution or chemical differences caused by primordial inhomogeneities, have not been ruled out. The paper also mentions that the metallicity difference between Krios and Kronos is much larger than the internal consistency level typically observed in stars of the same cluster, making them an important benchmark system for studying the limitations of chemical tagging methods. Furthermore, atomic diffusion effects were investigated, but they were found insufficient to fully explain the observed extreme metallicity difference. In summary, this paper aims to address the source of unusual chemical differences in binary systems, particularly in the case of Krios and Kronos. Their differences challenge the current understanding of star formation and evolution, calling for further research to refine models and theories.