Abstract:We revisit and generalize the notion of dilation distance ${\rm d_{D}}(u,v)$ between unitary tuples and study its relation to the natural Haagerup-Rørdam distance ${\rm d_{HR}}(u,v) = \inf\{\|\pi(u) - \rho(v)\|\}$, where the infimum is taken over all pairs of faithful representations $\pi \colon C^*(u) \to B(\mathcal{H})$, $\rho \colon C^*(v) \to B(\mathcal{H})$. We show that ${\rm d_{HR}}(u,v)\leq 10\operatorname{d_{rD}}(u,v)^{1/2}$, where ${\rm d_{rD}}(u,v)$ is a relaxed dilation distance, improving and extending earlier results. For an antisymmetric matrix $\Theta$, we show via a concrete dilation construction that a tuple of unitaries $u$ that almost commutes according to $\Theta$ (i.e., $\|u_\ell u_k - e^{i \theta_{k,\ell}} u_k u_\ell\|$ is small) can be nearly dilated to a tuple of unitaries $v$ that commutes according to $\Theta$ (i.e., $v_\ell v_k - e^{i \theta_{k,\ell}} v_k v_\ell = 0$). We show that the dilation can be "reversed" by a second application of the dilation construction, which leads to a rotated version of the original tuple. Thus, a gauge invariant almost $\Theta$-commuting unitary tuple can be approximated (in some faithful representation) by a $\Theta$-commuting unitary tuple. Moreover, when $\Theta$ is ergodic, a $\Theta$-commuting tuple is shown to be {\em almost} gauge invariant, and it follows from the results above that these can be approximated in norm by $\Theta$-commuting tuples. In particular, we obtain the following counterpart of Lin's theorem on almost commuting unitaries: if $q \in \mathbb{T}$ is {\em not} a root of unity, then for every $\varepsilon >0$ there exists $\delta > 0$ such that for every pair of unitaries $u_1,u_2 \in B(\mathcal{H})$ for which $\|u_1 u_2 - qu_2 u_1\| < \delta$, there exists two $q$-commuting unitaries $v_1, v_2 \in B(\mathcal{H} \otimes \ell^2)$ such that $\|v_i - u_i \otimes 1\| < \varepsilon$ ($i=1,2$).

Dilation distance and the stability of ergodic commutation relations

Classification and dilation for $q$-commuting $2 \times 2$ scalar matrices

Minimal unitary dilations for commuting contractions

Theory of $q$-commuting contractions-II: Regular $q$-unitary dilation and Brehmer's positivity

Dilations for operator-valued quantum measures

Isometric dilation and Sarason's commutant lifting theorem in several variables

Approximate orthogonality of permutation operators, with application to quantum information

Quantum implementation of non-unitary operations with biorthogonal representations

Andô dilations for a pair of commuting contractions: two explicit constructions and functional models

Matrix convexity and unitary power dilations of Toeplitz-contractive operator tuples

Dilation theorem via Schrödingerisation, with applications to the quantum simulation of differential equations

Dilation of normal operators associated with an annulus

Constructing Nearby Commuting Matrices for Ogata's Theorem on Macroscopic Observables

Commuting families of polygonal type operators on Hilbert space

The Dirac operator for the pair of Ruelle and Koopman operators, and a generalized Boson formalism

Strong asymptotic freeness for independent uniform variables on compact groups associated to nontrivial representations

Sequential commutation in tracial von Neumann algebras

On commuting pairs in arbitrary sets of 2x2 matrices

Zygmund dilations: bilinear analysis and commutator estimates

Commutators greater than a perturbation of the identity

Non-convergence of some non-commuting double ergodic averages