The History of Primordial Black Holes

Bernard J. Carr,Anne M. Green

2024-07-22

Abstract:We overview the history of primordial black hole (PBH) research from the first papers around 50 years ago to the present epoch. The history may be divided into four periods, the dividing lines being marked by three key developments: inflation on the theoretical front and the detection of microlensing events by the MACHO project and gravitational waves by the LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA project on the observation front. However, they are also characterised by somewhat different focuses of research. The period 1967-1980 covered the groundbreaking work on PBH formation and evaporation. The period 1980-1996 mainly focussed on their formation, while the period 1996-2016 consolidated the work on formation but also collated the constraints on the PBH abundance. In the period 2016-2024 there was a shift of emphasis to the search for evidence for PBHs and - while opinions about the strength of the purported evidence vary - this has motivated more careful studies of some aspects of the subject. Certainly the soaring number of papers on PBHs in this last period indicates a growing interest in the topic.

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the research history of primordial black holes (PBHs) and their importance in cosmology. Specifically, the paper reviews the research process of PBHs from the first relevant paper 50 years ago to the present, and divides it into four periods. The demarcation signs of each period are as follows:

1. **1967 - 1980**: This period mainly covers the pioneering work on the formation and evaporation of PBHs. In 1971, Hawking proposed a specific PBH formation scenario, and in 1974, he discovered Hawking radiation, which greatly promoted the interest in PBHs, but also implied observational limitations, making the existence of PBHs less likely.

2. **1980 - 1996**: This period mainly focused on the formation mechanism of PBHs, especially those formed from large - scale density perturbations. In addition, other formation mechanisms were explored, and the calculation of PBH evaporation was improved, thereby refining the abundance constraints.

3. **1996 - 2016**: During this period, the formation of PBHs continued to be studied, but at the same time, a large number of constraints on the abundance of PBHs were also carried out. These constraints mainly come from a variety of astrophysical and cosmological effects, such as evaporation, microlensing effects, dynamics, accretion, and gravitational waves. These constraints are expressed as the upper limits of the proportion of PBHs in dark matter in different mass ranges.

4. **2016 - 2024**: The focus of this period has shifted to finding evidence for the existence of PBHs. Although there are different opinions on the strength of this evidence, it has inspired more detailed research in some aspects. In particular, after the LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA project first detected the gravitational waves generated by the merger of multi - solar - mass black holes, the research interest in PBHs has increased significantly.

The main objective of the paper is to outline the historical development of PBH research, analyze the key progress and challenges in each period, and discuss the unique probing role of PBHs in fields such as the early universe, gravitational collapse, high - energy physics, and quantum gravity. By reviewing these studies, the paper aims to provide a comprehensive perspective to help readers understand the position and potential impact of PBHs in modern cosmology.