On Ambiguity and the Expressive Function of Law: The Role of Pragmatics in Smart Legal Ecosystems

Pompeu Casanovas

2024-06-08

Abstract:This is a long paper, an essay, on ambiguity, pragmatics, legal ecosystems, and the expressive function of law. It is divided into two parts and fifteen sections. The first part (Pragmatics) addresses ambiguity from the perspective of linguistic and cognitive pragmatics in the legal field. The second part (Computing) deals with this issue from the point of view of human-centered design and artificial intelligence, specifically focusing on the notion and modelling of rules and what it means to comply with the rules. This is necessary for the scaffolding of smart legal ecosystems (SLE). I will develop this subject with the example of the architecture, information flows, and smart ecosystem of OPTIMAI, an EU project of Industry 4.0 for zero-defect manufacturing (Optimizing Manufacturing Processes through Artificial Intelligence and Virtualization).

Computers and Society,Computation and Language

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper explores the ambiguity in legal language and its role in Smart Legal Ecosystems (SLE). The author discusses this from two perspectives:

1. **Linguistics and Cognitive Pragmatics Perspective**: This section mainly discusses how the ambiguity in legal language can be understood from the perspectives of linguistics and cognitive pragmatics. The author points out that the law influences society not only through its prescribed obligations, prohibitions, or permitted behaviors but also through its expression itself, which has social effects. For example, enacting a law that prohibits flag burning might lead to more people burning flags as a form of protest. This phenomenon can be explained by the concept of "counter-performative verbs" in linguistics, where certain linguistic actions actually hinder the goals they claim to achieve.

2. **Artificial Intelligence and Design Science Perspective**: This section explores how to construct smart legal ecosystems to address the ambiguity and uncertainty in legal language from the perspectives of artificial intelligence and design science. The author proposes a meso-level concept, suggesting that this level needs to be considered when designing smart legal systems to better handle interpretation issues in specific cases. Additionally, the author discusses how to indirectly regulate people's behavior through environmental design, such as reducing traffic accidents by changing traffic design rather than relying solely on explicit legal rules.

In summary, this paper aims to address the issue of understanding and dealing with ambiguity in legal language and explores how to use these understandings to design more effective smart legal ecosystems. This includes understanding the characteristics of legal language from a linguistic perspective and exploring how to achieve legal goals through technological means from a design science perspective.