Modeling Time-Variable Elemental Abundances in Coronal Loop Simulations

Jeffrey W. Reep,John Unverferth,Will T. Barnes,Sherry Chhabra

2024-07-24

Abstract:Numerous recent X-ray observations of coronal loops in both active regions (ARs) and solar flares have shown clearly that elemental abundances vary with time. Over the course of a flare, they have been found to move from coronal values towards photospheric values near the flare peak, before slowly returning to coronal values during the gradual phase. Coronal loop models typically assume that the elemental abundances are fixed, however. In this work, we introduce a time-variable abundance factor into the 0D ebtel++ code that models the changes due to chromospheric evaporation in order to understand how this affects coronal loop cooling. We find that for strong heating events ($\gtrsim$ 1 erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-3}$), the abundances quickly tend towards photospheric values. For smaller heating rates, the abundances fall somewhere between coronal and photospheric values, causing the loop to cool more quickly than the time-fixed photospheric cases (typical flare simulations) and more slowly than time-fixed coronal cases (typical AR simulations). This suggests heating rates in quiescent AR loops no larger than $\approx 0.1$ erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-3}$ to be consistent with recent measurements of abundance factors $f \gtrsim 2$.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily discusses the issue of elemental abundance variations over time in the solar corona loop and examines the impact of these changes on the cooling process of the corona loop. Specifically, the paper points out that recent X-ray observations show that elemental abundances are not constant during solar flares but change significantly over time. During flares, the elemental abundance shifts from typical coronal values towards photospheric values, then gradually returns to coronal values during the decay phase. However, existing models of the corona loop usually assume that elemental abundances are constant.

The authors of the paper introduced a time-variable abundance factor into the 0D ebtel++ code to simulate the changes in elemental abundance caused by chromospheric evaporation, thereby understanding how this affects the cooling of the corona loop. The study found that under intense heating events (greater than or equal to 1 erg s^-1 cm^-3), the elemental abundance quickly tends towards photospheric values. For smaller heating rates, the elemental abundance lies between coronal and photospheric values, resulting in a faster cooling rate of the corona loop compared to the fixed photospheric value scenario (typical flare simulation) but slower than the fixed coronal value scenario (typical active region simulation). This suggests that to be consistent with recently measured abundance factors, the heating rate in active region corona loops should not exceed about 0.1 erg s^-1 cm^-3.

The paper compares the hydrodynamic evolution of corona loops under fixed photospheric abundance, fixed coronal abundance, and time-variable abundance conditions by simulating loops of different lengths and various heating rates. The results indicate that the magnitude of the heating rate and the intensity of the resulting chromospheric evaporation play a significant role in the evolution of elemental abundance and radiative losses, thereby affecting the cooling rate of the corona loop. Additionally, the paper discusses the changes in elemental abundance during a nanoflare train (a series of consecutive nanoflare heating events) and the effects of these changes on temperature and density.

In summary, the paper reveals through theoretical modeling how chromospheric evaporation alters the elemental abundance in the corona loop, thereby affecting its radiative loss rate and cooling process, which is of significant importance for understanding the physical state of the corona loop during solar active regions and flares.