Abstract:When algorithmic harms emerge, a reasonable response is to stop using the algorithm to resolve concerns related to fairness, accountability, transparency, and ethics (FATE). However, just because an algorithm is removed does not imply its FATE-related issues cease to exist. In this paper, we introduce the notion of the "algorithmic imprint" to illustrate how merely removing an algorithm does not necessarily undo or mitigate its consequences. We operationalize this concept and its implications through the 2020 events surrounding the algorithmic grading of the General Certificate of Education (GCE) Advanced (A) Level exams, an internationally recognized UK-based high school diploma exam administered in over 160 countries. While the algorithmic standardization was ultimately removed due to global protests, we show how the removal failed to undo the algorithmic imprint on the sociotechnical infrastructures that shape students', teachers', and parents' lives. These events provide a rare chance to analyze the state of the world both with and without algorithmic mediation. We situate our case study in Bangladesh to illustrate how algorithms made in the Global North disproportionately impact stakeholders in the Global South. Chronicling more than a year-long community engagement consisting of 47 inter-views, we present the first coherent timeline of "what" happened in Bangladesh, contextualizing "why" and "how" they happened through the lenses of the algorithmic imprint and situated algorithmic fairness. Analyzing these events, we highlight how the contours of the algorithmic imprints can be inferred at the infrastructural, social, and individual levels. We share conceptual and practical implications around how imprint-awareness can (a) broaden the boundaries of how we think about algorithmic impact, (b) inform how we design algorithms, and (c) guide us in AI governance.

L'algorithme : pourquoi et comment le d{é}finir pour l'enseigner

Algorithm Visualization for Teaching Principles of Compiler

Teaching Algorithm Design: A Literature Review

Exploration in Algorithm Engineering: Modeling Algorithms

Teaching computer code at school

An experience of teaching algorithms using inquiry-based learning

Apprentissage de la pensée informatique : de la formation des enseignant$\cdot$e$\cdot$s à la formation de tou$\cdot$te$\cdot$s les citoyen$\cdot$ne$\cdot$s

The Algorithm Of The Course Arranging In The Computer Classroom Based On Dfl

The Algorithmic Imprint

When is the Algorithm Concept Pertinent – and when Not? Thoughts about Algorithms and Paradigmatic Examples, and about Algorithmic and Non-Algorithmic Mathematical Cultures1

Discussion on Teaching Strategy of Algorithm in Primary School

A new course `Algebra + Computer Science': What should be its outcomes and where it should start

Methodology of Algorithm Engineering

EXPLICIT AND LESS EXPLICIT ALGORITHMIC THINKING, 1200-1500. JORDANUS DE NEMORE, AND THE CONTRAST BETWEEN BARTHELEMY DE ROMANS ET CHUQUET

PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS IN TEACHING ALGORITHMS AND DATA STRUCTURES

Le trading algorithmique

Designing for Critical Algorithmic Literacies

Teaching Programming for Mathematical Scientists

Mise en œuvre d'une ingénierie didactique de développement dans le cadre d'un travail collaboratif chercheur/enseignant lors de la conceptualisation des objets de l'Analyse au début du cursus dans le supérieur

A Learning Algorithm based on High School Teaching Wisdom

Le théorème des accroissements finis comme question curriculaire