End-to-End Trainable Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Relation Extraction

Kohei Makino,Makoto Miwa,Yutaka Sasaki

2024-10-10

Abstract:This paper addresses a crucial challenge in retrieval-augmented generation-based relation extractors; the end-to-end training is not applicable to conventional retrieval-augmented generation due to the non-differentiable nature of instance retrieval. This problem prevents the instance retrievers from being optimized for the relation extraction task, and conventionally it must be trained with an objective different from that for relation extraction. To address this issue, we propose a novel End-to-end Trainable Retrieval-Augmented Generation (ETRAG), which allows end-to-end optimization of the entire model, including the retriever, for the relation extraction objective by utilizing a differentiable selection of the $k$ nearest instances. We evaluate the relation extraction performance of ETRAG on the TACRED dataset, which is a standard benchmark for relation extraction. ETRAG demonstrates consistent improvements against the baseline model as retrieved instances are added. Furthermore, the analysis of instances retrieved by the end-to-end trained retriever confirms that the retrieved instances contain common relation labels or entities with the query and are specialized for the target task. Our findings provide a promising foundation for future research on retrieval-augmented generation and the broader applications of text generation in Natural Language Processing.

Computation and Language

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Aims to Solve

This paper aims to address a key challenge in the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) model for relation extraction tasks: traditional RAG models cannot be trained end-to-end because instance retrieval is a non-differentiable operation. This issue prevents the instance retriever from being optimized for the relation extraction task, often requiring the retriever to be trained with an objective function different from the relation extraction goal. To solve this problem, the authors propose a new end-to-end trainable Retrieval-Augmented Generation model (ETRAG), which uses a differentiable method for selecting the nearest instances, allowing the entire model (including the retriever) to be optimized end-to-end for the relation extraction task.

### Specific Problem Description

1. **Non-differentiable Operation Issue**:
- Instance retrieval in traditional RAG models is non-differentiable, meaning the operation of selecting the nearest instances cannot be optimized through gradient descent.
- This prevents the retriever from being trained end-to-end with the generation model, affecting the overall performance of the model.

2. **Retriever Optimization Issue**:
- Since the retriever cannot be trained with the generation model, it often needs to be trained separately, increasing development costs.
- A separately trained retriever may not adapt well to specific relation extraction tasks because its optimization goal is not aligned with the relation extraction task.

### Solution

1. **Differentiable Instance Selection**:
- ETRAG introduces a soft k-nearest neighbors (soft kNN) method to make the instance selection process differentiable. Specifically, it uses a weighted sum to select the nearest instances instead of direct sampling.
- This method calculates the weight of each instance and selects instances based on these weights, making the entire process differentiable and allowing for end-to-end training.

2. **Neural Prompting**:
- ETRAG also introduces neural prompting, converting the embeddings of selected instances into soft prompts rather than text prompts. These soft prompts are concatenated into the input sequence's embeddings, further enhancing the model's flexibility and adaptability.

### Experimental Validation

- **Datasets**:
- The authors conducted experiments on the TACRED dataset, a standard benchmark for relation extraction.
- To evaluate the impact of different amounts of training data, the authors also conducted experiments with varying proportions of the dataset.

- **Performance Evaluation**:
- Experimental results show that ETRAG outperforms baseline models in relation extraction performance on the TACRED dataset, especially when training data is limited.
- Analysis results indicate that ETRAG can select instances highly relevant to the target task, with over 70% of the selected instances containing the same entities or relation labels as the query.

### Conclusion

By introducing differentiable instance selection and neural prompting techniques, ETRAG successfully addresses the issue of traditional RAG models being unable to train end-to-end, improving performance in relation extraction tasks, particularly in low-resource settings. This research provides strong support for future applications of retrieval-augmented generation and text generation in natural language processing.