Abstract:We explore the question asking for graphs $G$ for which the total distance decreases, possibly by a fixed constant $k$, upon the removal of any of its vertices. We obtain results leading to intuition and doubts for the Šoltés' problem ($k=0$) and its conjectures.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems Addressed by the Paper
The paper explores a classic problem in graph theory, namely finding those graphs \( G \) where the total distance remains unchanged or decreases after the removal of any vertex. Specifically, the paper focuses on the **Šoltés Problem**, which was proposed by Šoltés in 1991. He observed that if a vertex is removed from an 11-cycle \( C_{11} \), the total distance does not change, and he inquired whether there exist other such graphs \( G \) (now known as **Šoltés Graphs**).
### Main Research Content
1. **Background and Motivation**:
- The Šoltés Problem is a fundamental question about the total distance \( W(G) \) of a graph.
- Previous research has found some examples, such as Spiro and Cambie discovering infinitely many examples in signed graphs and hypergraphs, respectively.
- There are currently many open conjectures about Šoltés Graphs, such as whether these graphs must be regular or vertex-transitive, and whether \( C_{11} \) is the only Šoltés Graph.
2. **Main Results**:
- The authors prove that if \( W(G) \leq W(G \setminus v) \) for all \( v \in V(G) \), then the diameter of the graph cannot be too small.
- If \( W(G) - W(G \setminus v) \) is constant for all \( v \in V(G) \), then \( G \) is either a cycle or has a minimum degree of at least 3.
- The authors present eight graphs where two-thirds of the vertices satisfy \( W(G \setminus v) = W(G) \) and provide conditional examples with a higher proportion of vertices meeting this condition.
3. **Extended Problems**:
- The authors propose a more general problem: for a fixed \( z \in \mathbb{Z} \), find all graphs \( G \) that satisfy \( W(G) - W(G \setminus v) = z \).
- The authors believe that this problem is almost impossible to solve in general, and the Šoltés Problem may also be very difficult or unsolvable.
4. **Counterexamples and Evidence**:
- The authors provide counterexamples to show that some natural conjectures may not hold, such as the existence of non-regular graphs that satisfy \( W(G) - W(G \setminus v) = z \).
- The authors also discuss some verification results in vertex-transitive graphs, indicating that under certain conditions, there may be a large number of negative Šoltés Graphs.
5. **Conclusions and Core Issues**:
- The authors pose a core question: whether there exist infinitely many negative Šoltés Graphs (i.e., graphs where \( W(G) < W(G \setminus v) \) for all \( v \in V(G) \)).
- The authors conjecture that if this question has a positive answer, then for each \( z \in \mathbb{Z} \), there exist infinitely many graphs \( G \) that satisfy \( W(G) - W(G \setminus v) = z \), and some of these are non-vertex-transitive graphs.
### Summary
Through a series of theoretical results and counterexamples, the paper explores the Šoltés Problem and its extended problems, proposes new conjectures, and points out directions for future research. The core issue is whether there exist infinitely many negative Šoltés Graphs, which will help to deepen the understanding of the properties of the total distance in graphs.