Superconductivity in twisted bilayer WSe$_2$

Yinjie Guo,Jordan Pack,Joshua Swann,Luke Holtzman,Matthew Cothrine,Kenji Watanabe,Takashi Taniguchi,David Mandrus,Katayun Barmak,James Hone,Andrew J. Millis,Abhay N. Pasupathy,Cory R. Dean

2024-06-06

Abstract:The discovery of superconductivity in twisted bilayer and twisted trilayer graphene has generated tremendous interest. The key feature of these systems is an interplay between interlayer coupling and a moiré superlattice that gives rise to low-energy flat bands with strong correlations. Flat bands can also be induced by moiré patterns in lattice-mismatched and or twisted heterostructures of other two-dimensional materials such as transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs). Although a wide range of correlated phenomenon have indeed been observed in the moiré TMDs, robust demonstration of superconductivity has remained absent. Here we report superconductivity in 5 degree twisted bilayer WSe$_2$ (tWSe$_2$) with a maximum critical temperature of 426 mK. The superconducting state appears in a limited region of displacement field and density that is adjacent to a metallic state with Fermi surface reconstruction believed to arise from antiferromagnetic order. A sharp boundary is observed between the superconducting and magnetic phases at low temperature, reminiscent of spin-fluctuation mediated superconductivity. Our results establish that moiré flat-band superconductivity extends beyond graphene structures. Material properties that are absent in graphene but intrinsic among the TMDs such as a native band gap, large spin-orbit coupling, spin-valley locking, and magnetism offer the possibility to access a broader superconducting parameter space than graphene-only structures.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to observe the superconducting phenomenon in twisted bilayer WSe₂ (tungsten diselenide) and explore its properties and mechanisms. Specifically, the researchers focus on the following aspects:

1. **Discovery of the superconducting phenomenon**: The paper reports the observation of the superconducting phenomenon in bilayer WSe₂ with a 5 - degree twist angle, and the highest critical temperature reaches 426 mK. This discovery expands the application range of the superconducting phenomenon in two - dimensional materials, especially for transition - metal dichalcogenides (TMDs).

2. **Relationship between superconductivity and magnetism**: The researchers observe that the superconducting phase appears in a limited displacement field and density region and is adjacent to a metallic state with Fermi - surface reconstruction. This metallic state is considered to be caused by antiferromagnetic order. In addition, there is an obvious boundary between the superconducting phase and the magnetic phase, which is similar to the spin - fluctuation - mediated superconducting phenomenon.

3. **Discussion on the superconducting mechanism**: The paper discusses the possible mechanisms of the superconducting phenomenon, especially whether it is mediated by spin fluctuations. By analyzing the superconducting - antiferromagnetic phase diagram, the researchers propose the hypothesis that superconductivity may be stabilized by spin fluctuations, similar to the behavior in heavy - fermion systems.

4. **Comparison with other systems**: The paper also discusses the similarities and differences between the superconducting phenomenon in twisted bilayer WSe₂ and that in graphene - based flat - band systems. It is specifically pointed out that WSe₂ has some characteristics that graphene does not have, such as an intrinsic bandgap, large spin - orbit coupling, spin - valley locking, and magnetism. These characteristics may enable WSe₂ to exhibit a wider range of possibilities in the superconducting parameter space.

### Main conclusions

- **Confirmation of the superconducting phenomenon**: The superconducting phenomenon has been observed in bilayer WSe₂ with a 5 - degree twist angle, and the highest critical temperature is 426 mK.
- **Relationship between superconductivity and magnetism**: There is an obvious boundary between the superconducting phase and the antiferromagnetic phase, indicating that superconductivity may be stabilized by spin fluctuations.
- **Discussion on the superconducting mechanism**: Although the system is in the weakly - paired BCS limit, superconductivity may be mediated by non - phonon mechanisms (such as spin fluctuations).
- **Comparison with other systems**: The characteristics of WSe₂ enable it to exhibit a wider range of possibilities in the superconducting parameter space, expanding the understanding of the superconducting phenomenon in two - dimensional materials.

### Formula presentation

- **Ratio of superconducting critical temperature to Fermi temperature**:
\[
\frac{T_c}{T_F}\sim0.0008
\]
where \(T_F = \frac{E_F}{k_B}\), \(E_F\) is the Fermi energy, and \(k_B\) is the Boltzmann constant.

- **Superfluid stiffness**:
\[
\rho_s(T_c)=\frac{2\pi T_c}{\phi_0}
\]
where \(\phi_0\) is the magnetic flux quantum.

- **Ratio of coherence length to moiré lattice constant**:
\[
\frac{\xi_0}{a_m}\sim15
\]

These formulas and conclusions show the in - depth exploration of the researchers in understanding the superconducting phenomenon and its mechanism in twisted bilayer WSe₂.