Vagus nerve stimulation: Laying the groundwork for predictive network-based computer models

John F. Ingham,Frances Hutchings,Paolo Zuliani,Yujiang Wang,Sadegh Soudjani,Peter N. Taylor

2024-06-05

Abstract:Vagus Nerve Stimulation (VNS) is an established palliative treatment for drug resistant epilepsy. While effective for many patients, its mechanism of action is incompletely understood. Predicting individuals' response, or optimum stimulation parameters, is challenging. Computational modelling has informed other problems in epilepsy but, to our knowledge, has not been applied to VNS. We started with an established, four-population neural mass model (NMM), capable of reproducing the seizure-like dynamics of a thalamocortical circuit. We extended this to include 18 further neural populations, representing nine other brain regions relevant to VNS, with connectivity based on existing literature. We modelled stimulated afferent vagal fibres as projecting to the nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS), which receives input from the vagus nerve in vivo. Bifurcation analysis of a deterministic version of the model showed higher background NTS input made the model monostable at a fixed point (FP), representing normal activity, while lower inputs produce bistability between the FP and a limit cycle (LC), representing the seizure state. Adding noise produced transitions between seizure and normal states. This stochastic model spent decreasing time in the seizure state with increasing background NTS input, until seizures were abolished, consistent with the deterministic model. Simulated VNS stimulation, modelled as a 30 Hz square wave, was summed with the background input to the NTS and was found to reduce total seizure duration in a dose-dependent manner, similar to expectations in vivo. We have successfully produced an in silico model of VNS in epilepsy, capturing behaviour seen in vivo. This may aid understanding therapeutic mechanisms of VNS in epilepsy and provides a starting point to (i) determine which patients might respond best to VNS, and (ii) optimise individuals' treatments.

Neurons and Cognition

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main goal of this paper is to develop a network-based computer model to simulate the mechanisms of vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) in the treatment of epilepsy. Specifically, the research team constructed a computational model capable of reproducing clinically observed behaviors, including the transition between normal states and seizure-like states, and simulating the effects of vagus nerve stimulation.

The main issues addressed in the paper include:

1. **Understanding the mechanism of VNS**: Although VNS has been widely adopted as an effective means of treating refractory epilepsy, its exact mechanism of action is not yet fully understood. By establishing a computational model, researchers hope to better understand how VNS affects brain activity and why some patients respond well to this therapy.

2. **Predicting patient response**: It is currently difficult to predict which patients will have the best response to VNS treatment. Through this model, researchers hope to identify biomarkers that can be used to predict patient treatment outcomes, aiding in the selection of the most suitable patient groups for VNS therapy.

3. **Optimizing individualized treatment plans**: The current selection of VNS parameters mainly relies on clinical experience and trial and error. Researchers hope to optimize treatment parameters for individual patients through the model to improve treatment efficacy.

In the paper, the research team extended existing four population neural mass models to include 18 additional neural populations across nine other brain regions related to VNS. They also simulated vagus nerve stimulation and found that with increased background input to the nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS), the simulated seizure duration decreased, which is consistent with clinical observations. Additionally, the study showed that altering stimulation parameters could further reduce the duration of seizures.

In summary, this work provides an important foundation for understanding the mechanisms of VNS, predicting patient response, and optimizing individualized treatment.