Abstract:The dynamics of phase transitions (PT) in quantum field theories at finite temperature is most accurately described within the framework of dimensional reduction. In this framework, thermodynamic quantities are computed within the 3-dimensional effective field theory (EFT) that results from integrating out the high-temperature Matsubara modes. However, strong-enough PTs, observable in gravitational wave (GW) detectors, occur often nearby the limit of validity of the EFT, where effective operators can no longer be neglected. Here, we perform a quantitative analysis of the impact of these interactions on the determination of PT parameters. We find that they allow for strong PTs in a wider region of parameter space, and that both the peak frequency and the amplitude of the resulting GW power spectrum can change by more than one order of magnitude when they are included. As a byproduct of this work, we derive equations for computing the bounce solution in the presence of higher-derivative terms, consistently with the EFT power counting.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of accurately calculating the phase - transition parameters at finite temperature in quantum field theory, especially in the case of strong phase transitions (i.e., first - order phase transitions). Specifically, the paper focuses on how to consider the influence of higher - order derivative terms on the phase - transition parameters within the framework of high - dimensional effective field theory (EFT). These parameters include the nucleation temperature \(T^*\), the latent heat \(\alpha\), the inverse of the phase - transition duration \(\beta/H^*\) and the bubble - wall velocity \(v_w\).
### Background of the Paper
In quantum field theory, phase transitions at finite temperature are usually described by the imaginary - time or Matsubara formalism. In this formalism, boson (fermion) fields are periodic (anti - periodic) functions of the imaginary time, and the imaginary time is compressed on a circle with a radius of \(1/T\), where \(T\) is the temperature of the heat bath. These fields can be regarded as Fourier series of thermal modes in Euclidean spacetime. In the high - temperature limit, a 4 - dimensional quantum field theory can be equivalent to a conventional 3 - dimensional Euclidean quantum field theory.
However, there are some difficulties in performing calculations in this framework, mainly including:
1. **Linde Problem**: The short - distance non - perturbative effects of massless vector bosons in non - Abelian gauge theories can only be captured by lattice simulations.
2. **Large - Logarithm Problem**: Large logarithms \(\log(T^2/m^2)\) that may appear in loop - diagram calculations, where \(m\) is a light mass, which may undermine the validity of perturbation theory.
3. **Non - uniform Field Configuration**: Calculating the phase - transition parameters requires evaluating the value of the effective action on the so - called "bounce solution", which is a non - uniform classical field configuration interpolating between two vacuum expectation values (VEVs). The effective action usually constructed is a derivative expansion around a constant field configuration, and this method fails in this case.
### Solutions
The paper improves the 3 - dimensional effective field theory by introducing higher - order derivative terms, which cannot be ignored near strong phase transitions. Specifically, the paper has carried out the following work:
1. **Model Setup**: Considered a model containing a real scalar field \(\phi\) and a massless fermion \(\psi\), and derived the corresponding 3 - dimensional EFT Lagrangian.
2. **Matching Conditions**: Calculated the 1PI correlation functions between the 4 - dimensional and 3 - dimensional theories and matched them to the tree - level 3 - dimensional theory.
3. **Phase - Transition Parameter Calculation**: Calculated the phase - transition parameters \(T^*\), \(\alpha\), \(\beta/H^*\) and \(v_w\) when considering higher - order derivative terms.
4. **Numerical Results**: Showed significant differences in the phase - transition parameters at different points in the parameter space, with and without higher - order derivative terms.
### Main Findings
1. **Extension of the Phase - Transition Range**: At most points in the parameter space, higher - order derivative terms allow phase transitions to occur within a wider range of Yukawa coupling values.
2. **Significant Parameter Changes**: In the case where a phase transition occurs, after including higher - order derivative terms, the predicted values of the phase - transition parameters \(T^*\), \(\alpha\), \(\beta/H^*\) and \(v_w\) can change significantly.
3. **Influence on the Gravitational - Wave Spectrum**: Changes in these parameters have a huge impact on the peak frequency and amplitude of the gravitational - wave power spectrum, and in some cases the amplitude can change by more than an order of magnitude.
### Conclusions
The paper provides strong evidence of the importance of considering effective field - theory effects when studying strong phase transitions. Future work can further consider higher - loop - diagram corrections and quantum corrections, as well as other physics models beyond the standard model.