Online network topology shapes personal narratives and hashtag generation

J. Hunter Priniski,Bryce Linford,Sai Krishna,Fred Morstatter,Jeff Brantingham,Hongjing Lu

2024-05-31

Abstract:While narratives have shaped cognition and cultures for centuries, digital media and online social networks have introduced new narrative phenomena. With increased narrative agency, networked groups of individuals can directly contribute and steer narratives that center our collective discussions of politics, science, and morality. We report the results of an online network experiment on narrative and hashtag generation, in which networked groups of participants interpreted a text-based narrative of a disaster event, and were incentivized to produce matching hashtags with their network neighbors. We found that network structure not only influences the emergence of dominant beliefs through coordination with network neighbors, but also impacts participants' use of causal language in their personal narratives.

Social and Information Networks,Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand how the structure of online social networks affects the behavior of personal narrative and hashtag generation. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following points:

1. **The influence of network structure on the formation of collective beliefs**: Researchers hope to understand how different types of network structures (for example, spatially - embedded networks and well - mixed networks) affect the ability of participants to coordinate in the network and generate dominant beliefs.

2. **The use of causal language in personal narratives**: Researchers are also concerned with whether and how network interactions change the way participants use causal language when describing events. By analyzing the "tweets" written by participants before and after the experiment, researchers can evaluate the impact of network interactions on their expression of causal relationships.

3. **The sensitivity of hashtag dynamics to network structure**: Researchers attempt to reveal the hashtag production patterns under specific network structures, especially which factors promote certain hashtags to become dominant hashtags while others are eliminated.

### Research Background

With the development of digital media and online social networks, people can participate in and shape public discussions in an unprecedented way. However, these platforms may also lead to the formation of echo chambers, thereby spreading unreliable information and conspiracy theories. Therefore, it is of great significance to understand how the network environment affects the information processing and belief formation of individuals and groups.

### Experimental Design

To answer the above questions, researchers designed an online network experiment. Participants were assigned to different network conditions and were required to write personal narratives and hashtags based on the given text of a disaster event. The experiment was divided into three stages:

- **Pre - interaction stage**: Participants read a narrative about the Fukushima nuclear disaster and wrote a "tweet" and ten hashtags.
- **Network interaction stage**: Participants interacted with other participants in a network environment. In each round of the experiment, they were required to write a hashtag based on the previous narrative and receive rewards according to the matching situation with their neighbors.
- **Post - interaction stage**: Participants wrote a "tweet" and ten hashtags again to evaluate the impact of network interactions on their narrative and hashtag selection.

### Main Findings

1. **Global connections support the emergence of dominant responses**: In well - mixed networks, dominant hashtags are more likely to emerge quickly because this network structure promotes the wide spread of information.

\[
\text{Proportion of dominant hashtags} \sim \beta_{\text{Trial}}+\beta_{\text{Trial} \times \text{Spatial}}+\beta_{\text{Size}}
\]

2. **Local connections support coordination within the community**: Although the emergence of dominant hashtags is slower in spatially - embedded networks, the coordination among participants within local communities is more effective, indicating that different local communities may reach an agreement around different hashtags.

3. **Changes in causal language**: Through natural language processing (NLP) methods, researchers found that after network interactions, participants are more inclined to use causal language when describing events, which reflects that their understanding of the causal relationship of events has changed.

### Conclusion

This research shows that network structure not only affects the ability of participants to coordinate and generate dominant beliefs in an online environment but also changes the way they use causal language in personal narratives. This finding is of great significance for understanding the mechanisms of information dissemination and social differentiation and is helpful for developing strategies to mitigate the spread of false information and reduce social division.