GenKubeSec: LLM-Based Kubernetes Misconfiguration Detection, Localization, Reasoning, and Remediation

Ehud Malul,Yair Meidan,Dudu Mimran,Yuval Elovici,Asaf Shabtai

2024-05-30

Abstract:A key challenge associated with Kubernetes configuration files (KCFs) is that they are often highly complex and error-prone, leading to security vulnerabilities and operational setbacks. Rule-based (RB) tools for KCF misconfiguration detection rely on static rule sets, making them inherently limited and unable to detect newly-discovered misconfigurations. RB tools also suffer from misdetection, since mistakes are likely when coding the detection rules. Recent methods for detecting and remediating KCF misconfigurations are limited in terms of their scalability and detection coverage, or due to the fact that they have high expertise requirements and do not offer automated remediation along with misconfiguration detection. Novel approaches that employ LLMs in their pipeline rely on API-based, general-purpose, and mainly commercial models. Thus, they pose security challenges, have inconsistent classification performance, and can be costly. In this paper, we propose GenKubeSec, a comprehensive and adaptive, LLM-based method, which, in addition to detecting a wide variety of KCF misconfigurations, also identifies the exact location of the misconfigurations and provides detailed reasoning about them, along with suggested remediation. When empirically compared with three industry-standard RB tools, GenKubeSec achieved equivalent precision (0.990) and superior recall (0.999). When a random sample of KCFs was examined by a Kubernetes security expert, GenKubeSec's explanations as to misconfiguration localization, reasoning and remediation were 100% correct, informative and useful. To facilitate further advancements in this domain, we share the unique dataset we collected, a unified misconfiguration index we developed for label standardization, our experimentation code, and GenKubeSec itself as an open-source tool.

Cryptography and Security,Computation and Language,Distributed, Parallel, and Cluster Computing,Machine Learning

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the misconfiguration problem in Kubernetes configuration files (KCFs). Specifically:

1. **Complexity and Error - Prone Nature of KCF**: KCFs are usually very complex and error - prone, which can lead to security vulnerabilities and operational problems.
2. **Limitations of Existing Tools**:
- **Rule - Based Tools (RB Tools)**: These tools rely on static rule sets and are unable to detect newly discovered misconfigurations, and are prone to false positives because errors may occur when writing detection rules.
- **Recent Approaches**: Although some new approaches have made progress in detecting and fixing KCF misconfigurations, there are still limitations in terms of scalability, detection coverage, or automated repair, or they require a high level of expertise.
- **Approaches Using Large Language Models (LLMs)**: Existing LLM - based approaches rely on API calls and have problems such as security challenges, inconsistent classification performance, and high cost.

To solve these problems, the authors propose GenKubeSec, an LLM - based comprehensive and adaptive approach aimed at detecting various KCF misconfigurations, determining their exact locations, and providing detailed explanations and repair suggestions. Compared with existing tools, GenKubeSec has the following advantages:

- **High Precision and Recall**: In experiments, GenKubeSec achieved a precision of 0.990 ± 0.020 and a recall of 0.999 ± 0.026, outperforming existing industry - standard tools.
- **Comprehensive Detection and Repair Capabilities**: It can not only detect misconfigurations but also accurately locate, explain the reasons, and provide repair suggestions.
- **Open Resources**: The authors share the unique data set collected, the Unified Misconfiguration Index (UMI), the experimental code, and GenKubeSec itself to promote further research and development.

Through these improvements, GenKubeSec can more effectively address KCF - related security risks and provide better detection and repair capabilities.