Abstract:The integration of traditional fixed-route transit (FRT) and more flexible microtransit has been touted as a means of improving mobility and access to opportunity, increasing transit ridership, and promoting environmental sustainability. To help evaluate integrated FRT and microtransit public transit (PT) system (henceforth ``integrated fixed-flex PT system'') designs, we propose a high-fidelity modeling framework that provides reliable estimates for a wide range of (i) performance metrics and (ii) integrated fixed-flex PT system designs. We formulate the mode choice equilibrium problem as a fixed-point problem wherein microtransit demand is a function of microtransit performance, and microtransit performance depends on microtransit demand. We propose a detailed agent-based simulation modeling framework that includes (i) a binary logit mode choice model (private auto vs. transit), (ii) a supernetwork-based model and pathfinding algorithm for multi-modal transit path choice where the supernetwork includes pedestrian, FRT, and microtransit layers, (iii) a detailed mobility-on-demand fleet simulator called FleetPy to model the supply-demand dynamics of the microtransit service. In this paper, we illustrate the capabilities of the modeling framework by analyzing integrated fixed-flex PT system designs that vary the following design parameters: FRT frequencies and microtransit fleet size, service region structure, virtual stop coverage, and operating hours. We include case studies in downtown San Diego and Lemon Grove, California. The computational results show that the proposed modeling framework converges to a mode choice equilibrium. Moreover, the scenario results imply that introducing a new microtransit service decreases FRT ridership and requires additional subsidies, but it significantly increases job accessibility and slightly reduces total VMT.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how to evaluate the effectiveness of integrating Fixed Route Transit (FRT) with flexible microtransit designs, particularly in terms of improving mobility, accessibility, and environmental sustainability of the transportation system. Specifically, the paper proposes a high-fidelity modeling framework for evaluating various design schemes of integrated fixed-route and flexible microtransit systems (referred to as "integrated fixed-flexible transit systems"). This framework aims to: 1. **Be sensitive to a wide range of transit design parameters**: Given the flexibility that transit agencies have in designing integrated fixed-flexible transit systems, the framework needs to handle variations in design parameters for both fixed-route transit and microtransit. 2. **Provide reliable performance metric estimates**: Since transit agencies face strict budget constraints and need to address various societal challenges (such as accessibility, mobility, environmental impact, and social equity), the framework needs to provide reliable estimates of a broad and relevant set of performance metrics. 3. **Reflect the heterogeneity of traveler behavior**: Most urban area travelers exhibit high heterogeneity; therefore, the framework needs to accurately reflect travelers' heterogeneous sensitivity to travel costs and their heterogeneous behavior in mode and route choice. 4. **Consider the impact of demand on system performance**: Given the scalability issues of microtransit services, the framework needs to reflect the substantial impact of total demand and the spatial and temporal distribution of demand on the performance of integrated fixed-flexible transit systems, particularly the performance of microtransit services. To achieve these goals, the paper proposes an agent-based simulation modeling framework that includes a binary Logit mode choice model (private car vs. public transit), a hypernetwork-based multimodal route choice model, and a detailed on-demand fleet simulator (FleetPy). These tools work together to capture the equilibrium between microtransit demand and performance, providing transit agencies with an effective tool to evaluate different integrated fixed-flexible transit system design schemes. The capabilities of this modeling framework are demonstrated through case studies in downtown San Diego and Lemon Grove, San Diego County. The results indicate that while the introduction of new microtransit services reduces the ridership of fixed-route transit and requires additional subsidies, it significantly improves job accessibility and slightly reduces the total vehicle miles traveled.

Flexible Agent-based Modeling Framework to Evaluate Integrated Microtransit and Fixed-route Transit Designs: Mode Choice, Supernetworks, and Fleet Simulation

Agent-Based Microsimulation Approach for Design and Evaluation of Flexible Work Schedules

Social Welfare Maximization of Multimodal Transportation

Simulating On-Demand Ride Services in a Manhattan-like Urban Network Considering Traffic Dynamics

An adaptive route choice model for integrated fixed and flexible transit systems

Integrating an agent-based behavioral model in microtransit forecasting and revenue management

Integrated Planning of Park-and-ride Facilities and Transit Service

Modeling Transit in a Fully Integrated Agent-Based Framework: Methodology and Large-Scale Application

Designing transit-oriented multi-modal transportation systems considering travelers’ choices

Dynamic Operations of an Integrated Mobility Service System of Fixed-Route Transits and Flexible Electric Buses

Deviated Fixed-route Microtransit: Design and Operations

Capturing Travel Mode Adoption in Designing On-demand Multimodal Transit Systems

Joint Optimization of Pattern, Headway, and Fleet Size of Multiple Urban Transit Lines with Perceived Headway Consideration and Passenger Flow Allocation

Transportation Interventions Reshaping NYC Commute: the Probabilistic Simulation Framework Assessing the Impacts of Ridesharing and Manhattan Congestion Surcharge

Planning of integrated mobility-on-demand and urban transit networks

Dynamic micro-assignment modeling approach for integrated multimodal urban corridor management

Plan Your System and Price for Free: Fast Algorithms for Multimodal Transit Operations

Evaluation methods of dynamic flexible transportation systems

Redesigning Large-Scale Multimodal Transit Networks with Shared Autonomous Mobility Services

Multimodal Transportation Pricing Alliance Design: Large-Scale Optimization for Rapid Gains

Integrated optimization of capacity allocation and timetable rescheduling for metro-based passenger and freight cotransportation