Abstract:In practical measurements, it is widely recognized that reducing the measurement time leads to decreased accuracy. On the other hand, whether an inherent speed-accuracy trade-off exists as a fundamental physical constraint for quantum measurements is not obvious, and the answer remains unknown. Here, we establish a fundamental speed-accuracy trade-off relation as a consequence of the energy conservation law and the locality. Our trade-off works as a no-go theorem that the zero-error measurement for the operators that are non-commutative with the Hamiltonian cannot be implemented with finite time and applies universally to various existing errors and disturbances defined for quantum measurements. We furthermore apply our methods to quantum computations and provide another speed-accuracy trade-off relation for unitary gate implementations, which works as another no-go theorem that any error-less implementations of quantum computation gates changing energy cannot be implemented with finite time, and a speed-disturbance trade-off for general quantum operations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether there exists a speed - accuracy trade - off relationship determined by fundamental physical laws in quantum measurement and computation. Specifically, the author explores whether error - free measurement or computation can be achieved within a finite time, and proposes a general speed - accuracy trade - off relationship as a consequence of the law of conservation of energy and locality. This relationship shows that for observables that do not commute with the system Hamiltonian, any error - free measurement requires an infinite amount of time to complete. Similarly, the error - free implementation of any quantum computing gate that changes energy also requires an infinite amount of time. In addition, the paper also provides a speed - disturbance trade - off relationship for general quantum operations.
### Main Contributions
1. **Establishing the Speed - Accuracy Trade - off Relationship**
- Through the law of conservation of energy and locality conditions, the author establishes the speed - accuracy trade - off relationship in quantum measurement. This relationship shows that for observables that do not commute with the Hamiltonian, any error - free measurement requires an infinite amount of time.
- Expressed by the formula:
\[
\epsilon(\rho, A, E) \geq \frac{1}{2} \left| \langle [H_S, A] \rangle_\rho \right| \frac{1}{K (R_0 + R_1 t)^d + c_1}
\]
where \(\epsilon(\rho, A, E)\) is the measurement error, \(H_S\) is the system Hamiltonian, \(A\) is the observable, \(t\) is the measurement time, and \(K, R_0, R_1, d, c_1\) are constants.
2. **Extension to Quantum Computation**
- The author further extends this relationship to the implementation of quantum computing gates and proposes the speed - accuracy trade - off relationship in the implementation of unitary quantum gates.
- Expressed by the formula:
\[
DF(\Lambda, U) \geq \frac{1}{4} C_U \frac{1}{K (R'_0 + R_1 t)^d + K_1}
\]
where \(DF(\Lambda, U)\) is the implementation error, \(C_U\) is a constant related to energy change, and other symbols are the same as above.
3. **Universal Applicability**
- These results are not only applicable to specific measurement systems but also have universal applicability to various defined errors and disturbances, including those defined by Arthurs - Kelly - Goodman (AKG), Ozawa, Watanabe - Sagawa - Ueda (WSU), Busch - Lahti - Werner (BLW), and Lee - Tsutsui (LT).
### Methods
- **The Concept of Irreversibility**: The author introduces error and disturbance definitions based on irreversibility, which can unify existing various error and disturbance definitions.
- **Local Interaction and Lieb - Robinson Bound**: Using the properties of local interaction and Lieb - Robinson bound, the author proves that the coherent resources required to implement quantum operations within a finite time are limited by the operation time.
- **The Law of Conservation of Energy**: Through the law of conservation of energy, the author proves that operations that locally change energy require a large amount of energy - coherent resources, which is inversely proportional to the irreversibility of the operation.
### Conclusions
- The results of the paper show that the implementation of any error - free quantum measurement or computing gate requires an infinite amount of time, which is a fundamental physical limitation determined by the law of conservation of energy and locality.
- These results are not only of great significance for quantum measurement and computation but also provide a new perspective for understanding the fundamental physical constraints in quantum systems.