Daniel Winkler,Christian Hotz-Behofsits,Nils Wlömert,Dominik Papies,Jura Liaukonyte
Abstract:The digital age has significantly changed how music is consumed, promoted, and monetized. Social media platforms like TikTok are playing a pivotal role in this transformation. This shift has sparked a debate within the music industry: While some stakeholders see social media platforms like TikTok as opportunities to boost songs to viral status, others raise concerns about potential cannibalization effects, fearing that such exposure might reduce revenue from streaming services like Spotify. In this paper, we evaluate the effect of a song's presence - or absence - on social media on its demand on music streaming services using a quasi-natural experiment: Universal Music Group's (UMG) - one of "The Big 3" record labels - decision to remove its entire content library from TikTok in February 2024. We use representative samples covering close to 50% of the US and 94% of the German streaming markets, employing a difference-in-differences approach to compare the streaming consumption of songs that were removed from TikTok with those that were not. We find that UMG's removal of music from TikTok led to a 2-3% increase in streams on audio platforms for affected songs, indicating substitution effects. However, this average treatment effect masks significant heterogeneity: older songs and songs with less promotional support elsewhere saw a decrease in streaming consumption, suggesting that TikTok helps consumers discover or rediscover content that is not top of mind for consumers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to explore the impact of social media on music demand, particularly the role of platforms like TikTok in music promotion and its effect on traditional music streaming services such as Spotify. Specifically, the paper evaluates the impact of the presence or absence of songs on TikTok on their demand on music streaming services by analyzing a quasi-natural experiment where Universal Music Group (UMG) decided to remove all its content from TikTok in February 2024.
### Background and Motivation
With the advent of the digital age, the ways music is consumed, promoted, and monetized have undergone significant changes. Social media platforms like TikTok have played a crucial role in this transformation. However, this change has sparked controversy within the music industry:
- **Supporters** argue that social media platforms like TikTok can propel songs to viral status, thereby increasing their play counts on streaming services.
- **Opponents** worry that these platforms might create a "cannibalization effect," where free music consumption reduces users' spending on paid streaming services, thus affecting revenue.
### Research Methodology
To assess the impact of TikTok on music streaming demand, the authors employed the Difference-in-Differences (DiD) method, comparing the changes in play counts on streaming services for songs removed from TikTok with those that were not removed. The study's data comes from two major music markets, the United States and Germany, covering nearly 50% of the US market and 94% of the German market.
### Key Findings
- **Overall Effect**: After UMG removed content from TikTok, the affected songs saw a 2-3% increase in play counts on audio platforms, indicating a substitution effect.
- **Heterogeneity**: This average treatment effect masks significant heterogeneity:
- Older songs and songs with less promotion on other channels saw a decrease in play counts on streaming services, suggesting that TikTok helps consumers discover or rediscover content that is not on their radar.
- Songs with more playlist followers performed better after being removed from TikTok, while those with fewer playlist followers were negatively impacted.
- Newer songs were less affected by the removal, whereas older songs were more significantly impacted.
### Conclusion
By analyzing the quasi-natural experiment of UMG withdrawing content from TikTok, the paper concludes that TikTok has a complex impact on music streaming demand. Although the overall removal of content led to a substitution effect, different types of songs exhibited significant variations in performance during this process. These findings are crucial for understanding the role of social media platforms in music promotion and their impact on traditional streaming services.