Abstract:The COVID-19 outbreak implied many changes in the daily life of most of the world's population for a long time, prompting severe restrictions on sociality. The Behavioral Immune System (BIS) suggests that when facing pathogens, a psychological mechanism would be activated that, among other things, would generate an increase in prejudice and discrimination towards marginalized groups, including immigrants. This study aimed to test if people tend to enhance their rejection of minorities and foreign groups under the threat of contagious diseases, using the users' attitudes towards migrants in Twitter data from Chile, for pre-pandemic and pandemic contexts. Our results only partially support the BIS hypothesis, since threatened users increased their tweet production in the pandemic period, compared to empathetic users, but the latter grew in number and also increased the reach of their tweets between the two periods. We also found differences in the use of language between these types of users. Alternative explanations for these results may be context-dependent.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **In the context of infectious disease threats (such as the COVID - 19 pandemic), has people's xenophobic sentiment increased?** Specifically, the authors hope to verify a core view of the Behavioral Immune System (BIS) hypothesis, that is, when facing the threat of infectious diseases, people will strengthen their exclusion of minorities and foreigners. To test this hypothesis, the researchers used Twitter data to analyze the changes in the attitudes of Chilean users towards immigrants before and after the pandemic. ### Research Background and Motivation 1. **Behavioral Immune System (BIS) Hypothesis**: - The behavioral immune system is a psychological defense mechanism aimed at detecting and avoiding infectious diseases. - When facing pathogens, the BIS will be activated, leading people to have more prejudice and discrimination against marginalized groups (including immigrants) (Schaller, 2006; Schaller and Park, 2011; Mortensen et al., 2010). 2. **Deficiencies in Existing Literature**: - Most existing studies rely on survey methods to correlate xenophobia with pathogen avoidance, lacking empirical evidence based on behavioral data (Navarrete and Fessler, 2006). - This study fills this gap by analyzing statements on Twitter, providing a more dynamic and easily accessible data source. ### Research Objectives The main objectives of the study are to test the following hypotheses: - During the pandemic, people who perceive higher disease vulnerability will show stronger negative emotions towards foreigners. - Specifically: - The number of users with a threatening attitude increases (or the number of users with a sympathetic attitude decreases). - The number of tweets by users with a threatening attitude increases (or the number of tweets by users with a sympathetic attitude decreases). - The number of retweets of tweets by users with a threatening attitude increases (or the number of retweets of tweets by users with a sympathetic attitude decreases). - The language of users with a threatening attitude involves more COVID - 19 - related words, especially during the pandemic. ### Method Overview 1. **Dataset Description**: - The data comes from the Twitter platform, covering tweets about immigrants from June to August 2019 (before the pandemic) and from June to August 2020 (after the pandemic). - A total of 892,487 tweets were collected, of which 299,098 were before the pandemic and 593,389 were after the pandemic. 2. **Attitude Classification**: - Using keyword and pattern recognition techniques, users are divided into two attitude categories: "sympathetic" and "threatening". - Apply the XGBoost classifier to train the model to predict the classification of unlabeled users. 3. **Result Analysis**: - Compare the number of tweets, the number of retweets, and language use of users with different attitudes before and after the pandemic. - Analyze the changes in high - frequency words, especially those related to the epidemic. ### Main Findings - **Overall Trend**: - After the pandemic, the proportion of users with a sympathetic attitude increased significantly, while the proportion of users with a threatening attitude decreased. - This trend is particularly evident among active users (those who post more than 14 tweets). - **Tweet Activity**: - The number of tweets by users with a threatening attitude increased during the pandemic, but the increase was not as significant as that of users with a sympathetic attitude. - The proportion of retweets of tweets by users with a sympathetic attitude increased significantly after the pandemic. - **Language Use**: - Users with a sympathetic attitude use more neutral and equal words, such as "children", "women", "men", "people", etc. - Users with a threatening attitude use more negative words, such as "illegal", "invasion", "infection", etc., especially during the pandemic, and mention more words related to the epidemic. ### Conclusion The research results partially support the BIS hypothesis, indicating that although the number of tweets by users with a threatening attitude did increase during the pandemic, overall, the number and influence of users with a sympathetic attitude are greater. This may mean that in the face of infectious disease threats, the overall social response is more complex, not simply exclusion and discrimination. Through this study, the authors not only verified part of the BIS hypothesis, but also provided...

Attitudes Towards Migration in a COVID-19 Context: Testing a Behavioral Immune System Hypothesis with Twitter Data

Characterization of Local Attitudes Toward Immigration Using Social Media

Clearance of apoptotic photoreceptors: elimination of apoptotic debris into the subretinal space and macrophage-mediated phagocytosis via phosphatidylserine receptor and integrin alphavbeta3.

Pandemic threat and intergroup relations: how negative emotions associated with the threat of Covid-19 shape attitudes towards immigrants

Personality trait analysis during the COVID-19 pandemic: a comparative study on social media

The social stratification of internal migration and daily mobility during the COVID-19 pandemic

Immigration and Gender as Social Determinants of Mental Health during the COVID-19 Outbreak: The Case of US Latina/os

Social media and anti-immigrant prejudice: a multi-method analysis of the role of social media use, threat perceptions, and cognitive ability

Exploring the Evolution of Sentiment in Spanish Pandemic Tweets: A Data Analysis Based on a Fine-Tuned BERT Architecture

Healthcare and social needs of international migrants during the COVID-19 pandemic in Latin America: analysis of the Chilean case

An Exploration of Geo-temporal Characteristics of Users' Reactions on Social Media During the Pandemic

The psychological costs of behavioral immunity following COVID-19 diagnosis

Inequalities in health outcomes of SARS-CoV-2 infection by migration status in Barcelona, Spain

The impact of human behavioral adaptation stratified by immune status on COVID-19 spread with application to South Korea

Nd:YAG laser influence on microtensile bond strength of different adhesive systems for human dentin.

Tracking the evolution of crisis processes and mental health on social media during the COVID-19 pandemic

Pandemic distress and anti‐immigration sentiments

Reduced mobility? Urban exodus? Medium-term impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on internal population movements in Latin American countries

Dynamics of social media behavior before and after SARS-CoV-2 infection

Hope Amid of a Pandemic: Is Psychological Distress Alleviating in South America while Coronavirus is still on Surge?