Emergent behaviour and phase transitions in spatially distributed multi-cellular metabolic networks

K. Narayanankutty,J. A. Pereiro-Morejon,A. Ferrero,V. Onesto,S. Forciniti,L. L. del Mercato,R. Mulet,A. De Martino,D. S. Tourigny,D. De Martino

2024-05-22

Abstract:Overflow metabolism is a ubiquitous phenomenon whereby cells in aerobic conditions excrete byproducts of glycolysis, such as lactate or acetate, into the medium in a seemingly wasteful and polluting fashion. Whilst overflow may confer microbes a fitness advantage by allowing them to overcome a finite oxidative capacity, its occurrence in higher organisms is harder to assess. Important insight was however obtained in recent experiments conducted at single-cell resolution, which revealed that accumulation of overflow products in tumor cell cultures known as the Warburg effect arises from imbalances in the dynamic and heterogeneous inter-cellular exchange network through which cells collectively regulate the microenvironment. Here we provide a quantitative characterization of this scenario by integrating metabolic network modeling with diffusion constraints, statistical physics theory and single-cell experimental flux data. On the theoretical side, we clarify how diffusion-limited exchanges shape the space of viable metabolic states of a multi-cellular system. Specifically, a phase transition from a balanced network of exchanges to an unbalanced overflow regime occurs as the mean cellular glucose and oxygen uptakes vary while single-cell metabolic phenotypes are highly heterogeneous around this transition. We then show that time-resolved data from human tumor-stroma cell co-cultures consistently map to this crossover region, supporting the idea that environmental deterioration reflects a failure of coordination among recurrently interacting cells. In summary, our findings suggest that, rather than deriving from multiple independent cell-autonomous processes, environmental control is an emergent feature of multi-cellular systems.

Statistical Mechanics,Biological Physics,Cell Behavior

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the phenomenon of overflow metabolism in multicellular metabolic networks, particularly the behavior and phase transitions in spatially distributed cell populations. Overflow metabolism refers to the waste and pollution of byproducts of sugar glycolysis, such as lactic acid or acetic acid, that cells excrete into the environment under aerobic conditions. While this phenomenon may provide adaptive advantages in microorganisms by increasing growth rate, its causes are more difficult to evaluate in higher organisms or tumor cells.

The study found that the "Warburg effect" in tumor cell culture (the aerobic glycolysis of tumor cells) is caused by the imbalance in dynamic and heterogeneous exchange networks between cells, which jointly regulate the microenvironment. The paper quantitatively describes this phenomenon by integrating metabolic network models, diffusion constraints, statistical physics theories, and single-cell experimental data.

The theoretical analysis reveals how diffusion-limited exchanges shape the feasible metabolic state space of multicellular systems and suggests a phase transition from equilibrium exchange networks to imbalanced overflow states as the average glucose and oxygen uptake of cells vary. Experimental data indicate that time-resolved data from co-cultures of human tumor-matrix cells are consistent with this phase transition region, indicating a failure of coordination between cells reflected in environmental deterioration.

The paper concludes that environmental control does not arise from independent cell autonomous processes, but rather is an emergent characteristic of collective behavior in multicellular systems. Cell populations adapt to the environment through two different levels: intracellular regulation (such as metabolism, signal transduction, gene regulation) and extracellular mechanisms (such as sensing, signal transmission, and movement), to control exchanges with the environment. The integration of these two levels is crucial for adaptability, survival, and ultimately fitness.