The Narrow Depth and Breadth of Corporate Responsible AI Research

Nur Ahmed,Amit Das,Kirsten Martin,Kawshik Banerjee

2024-05-21

Abstract:The transformative potential of AI presents remarkable opportunities, but also significant risks, underscoring the importance of responsible AI development and deployment. Despite a growing emphasis on this area, there is limited understanding of industry's engagement in responsible AI research, i.e., the critical examination of AI's ethical, social, and legal dimensions. To address this gap, we analyzed over 6 million peer-reviewed articles and 32 million patent citations using multiple methods across five distinct datasets to quantify industry's engagement. Our findings reveal that the majority of AI firms show limited or no engagement in this critical subfield of AI. We show a stark disparity between industry's dominant presence in conventional AI research and its limited engagement in responsible AI. Leading AI firms exhibit significantly lower output in responsible AI research compared to their conventional AI research and the contributions of leading academic institutions. Our linguistic analysis documents a narrower scope of responsible AI research within industry, with a lack of diversity in key topics addressed. Our large-scale patent citation analysis uncovers a pronounced disconnect between responsible AI research and the commercialization of AI technologies, suggesting that industry patents rarely build upon insights generated by the responsible AI literature. This gap highlights the potential for AI development to diverge from a socially optimal path, risking unintended consequences due to insufficient consideration of ethical and societal implications. Our results highlight the urgent need for industry to publicly engage in responsible AI research to absorb academic knowledge, cultivate public trust, and proactively mitigate AI-induced societal harms.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper investigates the level of involvement of artificial intelligence (AI) companies in AI research by leaders. Despite the tremendous potential and risks that AI technology brings, the study found that most AI companies have limited engagement in this critical field and are insufficiently invested in ethical, social, and legal AI review. By analyzing a large number of peer-reviewed articles and patent citations, the paper reveals that the industry's output in responsible AI research is significantly lower compared to traditional AI research and also less compared to academic institutions' contributions. Additionally, there is a clear disconnect between AI research and its commercialization within companies, indicating insufficient application of responsible AI insights in practical technological aspects. These findings underscore the urgency for companies to actively participate in responsible AI research in the public domain, to absorb academic knowledge, build public trust, and prevent and mitigate potential societal harms caused by AI.