Abstract:Large language models (LLMs) can pass explicit social bias tests but still harbor implicit biases, similar to humans who endorse egalitarian beliefs yet exhibit subtle biases. Measuring such implicit biases can be a challenge: as LLMs become increasingly proprietary, it may not be possible to access their embeddings and apply existing bias measures; furthermore, implicit biases are primarily a concern if they affect the actual decisions that these systems make. We address both challenges by introducing two new measures of bias: LLM Implicit Bias, a prompt-based method for revealing implicit bias; and LLM Decision Bias, a strategy to detect subtle discrimination in decision-making tasks. Both measures are based on psychological research: LLM Implicit Bias adapts the Implicit Association Test, widely used to study the automatic associations between concepts held in human minds; and LLM Decision Bias operationalizes psychological results indicating that relative evaluations between two candidates, not absolute evaluations assessing each independently, are more diagnostic of implicit biases. Using these measures, we found pervasive stereotype biases mirroring those in society in 8 value-aligned models across 4 social categories (race, gender, religion, health) in 21 stereotypes (such as race and criminality, race and weapons, gender and science, age and negativity). Our prompt-based LLM Implicit Bias measure correlates with existing language model embedding-based bias methods, but better predicts downstream behaviors measured by LLM Decision Bias. These new prompt-based measures draw from psychology's long history of research into measuring stereotype biases based on purely observable behavior; they expose nuanced biases in proprietary value-aligned LLMs that appear unbiased according to standard benchmarks.

Exploring Subjectivity for more Human-Centric Assessment of Social Biases in Large Language Models

Bias and Fairness in Large Language Models: A Survey

Evaluating and Mitigating Social Bias for Large Language Models in Open-ended Settings

Towards Understanding and Mitigating Social Biases in Language Models

An Actionable Framework for Assessing Bias and Fairness in Large Language Model Use Cases

The African Woman is Rhythmic and Soulful: An Investigation of Implicit Biases in LLM Open-ended Text Generation

Measuring Implicit Bias in Explicitly Unbiased Large Language Models

Decoding Biases: Automated Methods and LLM Judges for Gender Bias Detection in Language Models

Uncovering Biases with Reflective Large Language Models

Subtle Biases Need Subtler Measures: Dual Metrics for Evaluating Representative and Affinity Bias in Large Language Models

"Im not Racist but...": Discovering Bias in the Internal Knowledge of Large Language Models

LangBiTe: A Platform for Testing Bias in Large Language Models

Different Bias Under Different Criteria: Assessing Bias in LLMs with a Fact-Based Approach

Ask LLMs Directly, "What shapes your bias?": Measuring Social Bias in Large Language Models

People's Perceptions Toward Bias and Related Concepts in Large Language Models: A Systematic Review

Interpreting Bias in Large Language Models: A Feature-Based Approach

Towards detecting unanticipated bias in Large Language Models

Evaluating Implicit Bias in Large Language Models by Attacking From a Psychometric Perspective

Modeling Human Subjectivity in LLMs Using Explicit and Implicit Human Factors in Personas

Breaking Bias, Building Bridges: Evaluation and Mitigation of Social Biases in LLMs via Contact Hypothesis