Capacity Allocation for Cruise Lines Revenue Management:EMSR-a VS EMSR-b
SUN Xiaodong,FENG Xuegang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-5006.2013.011.004
2013-01-01
Abstract:In recent years,the cruise industry has evolved considerably and emerged to become one of the most rapid developed sectors in the global tourism and hospitality industry,with millions of passengers each year. Annual data from the Cruise Lines International Association( CLIA) indicated that during the period of 1990 to 2012,the number of cruise passengers has grown at an annual rate of over 7%,with14. 82 million in 2010,16. 37 million in2011 and estimated 17. 2 million in 2012. For an industry with explosive growth,however,the cruise sector has attracted a lack of research attention from international researchers. Very limited academic literature has touched this niche form of tourism. Particularly,research on cruise line revenue management has almost been neglected.Like airlines and hotels,cruise lines report all common characteristics of revenue management( RM):segmented market,fixed or constrained capacity,perishable inventory,finite selling horizons,reservation-based sales,and fluctuated demand. In cruise ships,cabins are divided into different types,i. e.,balcony,interior,ocean view,portholes,suite and deck level( upper or lower),with different kinds of fare classes. Each kind of cabin has fixed capacities and is sold in advance over a finite booking window. The purpose of cruise lines is to sell a fixed capacity of perishable products to different customer segments over a finite booking horizon in order to maximize the total expected revenue,through various revenue management practices including demand forecasting,demand function estimation,capacity control / allocation,and dynamic pricing. The quality of RM decisions,such as pricing and capacity control,depends on an accurate demand forecast or demand function estimation,to a large extent.The goal of capacity control is to allocate cruise cabins profitably by deciding booking limits for low-priced cabin types or reservation levels for high-priced cabins types from the start to the end of the selling period.Capacity-constrained companies usually set different booking limits in different periods to allocate the fixed capacity to the right customer at the right time. Methods of capacity allocation have been widely studied in airline and hotel RM,but the cruise line industry has received little research attention.In this article,the problem of capacity allocation for cruise line revenue management is considered. We compare the performance of two Expected Marginal Seat Revenue(EMSR) algorisms: EMSR-a and EMSR-b. First of all,a variety of probability distributions,such as Normal distribution,Log-normal distribution,Exponential distribution,Poisson distribution,Gamma distribution,Weibull distribution,Rayleigh distribution and Negative Binomial distribution,are tested to determine the real distributions behind the data of total bookings at cabin type level. The results offer evidence of a reasonable fit for the Normal distribution and Gamma distribution to the data.Then,without loss of generality,normal distribution is used to estimate the demand information for three kinds of cabin types. EMSR-a and EMSR-b are applied to determine the protection level for each cabin type. We simulate four demand situations of combinations of high and low total demand with high low-priced demand and high highpriced demand. Finally,the performance of these two heuristics algorithms is compared. Our results show mixed performance,with neither method dominating the other under different demand situations.