Estimating Idea Production: A Methodological Survey

Ege Erdil,Tamay Besiroglu,Anson Ho
2024-05-17
Abstract:Accurately modeling the production of new ideas is crucial for innovation theory and endogenous growth models. This paper provides a comprehensive methodological survey of strategies for estimating idea production functions. We explore various methods, including naive approaches, linear regression, maximum likelihood estimation, and Bayesian inference, each suited to different data availability settings. Through case studies ranging from total factor productivity to software R&D, we show how to apply these methodologies in practice. Our synthesis provides researchers with guidance on strategies for characterizing idea production functions and highlights obstacles that must be addressed through further empirical validation.
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to address the estimation problem of idea production functions in innovation theory and endogenous growth models. Specifically, the paper provides a comprehensive methodological survey of various strategies to estimate idea production functions and explores different methods under various data availability settings, including naive methods, linear regression, maximum likelihood estimation, and Bayesian inference. Through multiple case studies, ranging from total factor productivity to software R&D, the practical applications of these methods are demonstrated. Additionally, the paper identifies issues that require further empirical validation and emphasizes the challenges encountered in practical implementation, such as data insufficiency, model misidentification, and strong correlations between input and output measures. The ultimate goal is to provide guidance to researchers, helping them better understand and characterize idea production functions, and to highlight areas where existing empirical practices need improvement.