Abstract:Building on the recent development of the model-free generalized fiducial (MFGF) paradigm (Williams, 2023) for predictive inference with finite-sample frequentist validity guarantees, in this paper, we develop an MFGF-based approach to decision theory. Beyond the utility of the new tools we contribute to the field of decision theory, our work establishes a formal connection between decision theories from the perspectives of fiducial inference, conformal prediction, and imprecise probability theory. In our paper, we establish pointwise and uniform consistency of an {\em MFGF upper risk function} as an approximation to the true risk function via the derivation of nonasymptotic concentration bounds, and our work serves as the foundation for future investigations of the properties of the MFGF upper risk from the perspective of new decision-theoretic, finite-sample validity criterion, as in Martin (2021).

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to develop a decision theory approach based on Model-Free Generalized Fiducial (MFGF) inference. MFGF is a predictive inference method that uses imprecise probability theory to provide frequency guarantees for finite samples. The researchers have built a new decision theory on this basis and established formal connections between fiducial inference, consistency prediction, and imprecise probability theory in decision theory. The paper first introduces the importance of decision theory, which aims to determine the optimal decision rule based on observed data. Then, the paper proposes an upper bound risk function based on MFGF, which serves as an approximation to the true risk function and proves its point-wise convergence and consistency through non-asymptotic concentration bounds. In addition, the paper discusses how to use this upper bound risk function for decision-making, especially in the context of imprecise probability inference. The paper also explores the point-wise and uniform convergence of the MFGF upper bound risk function, and provides a numerical example based on an asymmetric loss function to demonstrate how the MFGF upper bound risk approaches the true risk as the sample size increases. With these results, the paper lays the foundation for future research on the new decision theory and finite sample efficiency criteria of MFGF upper bound risk. In conclusion, this paper is dedicated to addressing how to establish an effective decision theory framework using MFGF inference in situations of uncertainty and finite samples, and provides a new approach for assessing risks.

Decision theory via model-free generalized fiducial inference

Improving Robust Decisions with Data

Fiducial inference viewed through a possibility-theoretic inferential model lens

A Geometric Perspective on Bayesian and Generalized Fiducial Inference

Semiparametric fiducial inference

Decision-Focused Uncertainty Quantification

The fiducial-Bayes fusion: A general theory of statistical inference

Extended Fiducial Inference: Toward an Automated Process of Statistical Inference

Functional Decision Theory: A New Theory of Instrumental Rationality

Inferential models: A framework for prior-free posterior probabilistic inference

Fusing independent inferential models in a black-box manner

Large-sample theory for inferential models: a possibilistic Bernstein--von Mises theorem

Decisions Under Uncertainty as Bayesian Inference on Choice Options

Model-Free Reinforcement Learning with the Decision-Estimation Coefficient

Robust Data-Driven Decisions Under Model Uncertainty

Bridging Bayesian, frequentist and fiducial (BFF) inferences using confidence distribution

Conformal Decision Theory: Safe Autonomous Decisions from Imperfect Predictions

A New Decision Support Model in Multi-Criteria Decision Making with Intuitionistic Fuzzy Sets Based on Risk Preferences and Criteria Reduction

A fiducial approach to the nonparametric deconvolution problem: The discrete case

Decision making in stochastic extensive form I: Stochastic decision forests

From Cognitive to Computational Modeling: Text-based Risky Decision-Making Guided by Fuzzy Trace Theory