A Farewell to Harms: Risk Management for Medical Devices via the Riskman Ontology & Shapes

Piotr Gorczyca,Dörthe Arndt,Martin Diller,Pascal Kettmann,Stephan Mennicke,Hannes Strass

2024-05-22

Abstract:We introduce the Riskman ontology & shapes for representing and analysing information about risk management for medical devices. Risk management is concerned with taking necessary precautions so a medical device does not cause harms for users or the environment. To date, risk management documentation is submitted to notified bodies (for certification) in the form of semi-structured natural language text. We propose to use classes from the Riskman ontology to logically model risk management documentation and to use the included SHACL constraints to check for syntactic completeness and conformity to relevant standards. In particular, the ontology is modelled after ISO 14971 and the recently published VDE Spec 90025. Our proposed methodology has the potential to save many person-hours for both manufacturers (when creating risk management documentation) as well as notified bodies (when assessing submitted applications for certification), and thus offers considerable benefits for healthcare and, by extension, society as a whole.

Artificial Intelligence,Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main objective of this paper is to propose a new method for managing and analyzing risk management documents for medical devices by using logical modeling (Riskman ontology) and SHACL (Shapes Constraint Language) to check whether these documents comply with relevant standards.

Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Improving Efficiency**: Existing risk management documents are submitted to certification bodies in semi-structured natural language text form, which leads to a significant amount of manual work, especially for certification bodies (such as those in the EU) that need to evaluate these documents. The proposed Riskman ontology and SHACL constraints can enable automatic checking of the documents, thereby saving a substantial amount of work time.

2. **Standardization and Consistency**: Through logical modeling, it can be ensured that risk management documents follow a consistent standard format, such as ISO 14971 and the recently released VDE Spec 90025. This helps to improve the consistency and standardization level of the documents.

3. **Enhanced Navigation and Retrieval Capabilities**: Using semantically enhanced methods can improve the navigation and retrieval capabilities of the documents, allowing reviewers to find relevant information more quickly.

4. **Support for Reuse**: Parts of the risk management process can be reused in different contexts, such as when manufacturers update already certified devices. The Riskman ontology and methodology aim to support this reuse and may allow for technical reuse across manufacturers, which is particularly important for small and medium-sized enterprises.

5. **Simplifying Compliance Checks**: Through logical reasoning steps and SHACL constraint checks, it is possible to automatically verify whether the risk management documents meet specific requirements, such as whether each identified risk has corresponding mitigation measures.

6. **Promoting the Application of Semantic Web Technologies**: By adopting Semantic Web technologies in the medical device industry, not only can the quality of risk reports be directly improved, but the acceptance and application of these technologies across the industry can also be promoted.

In summary, this paper aims to improve the efficiency, consistency, and reusability of the medical device risk management system by developing the Riskman ontology and related SHACL constraints, thereby having a positive impact on healthcare and society as a whole.