Comparison of WarpX and GUINEA-PIG for electron positron collisions

Bao Nguyen,Arianna Formenti,Remi Lehe,Jean-Luc Vay,Spencer Gessner,Luca Fedeli
2024-05-15
Abstract:As part of the Snowmass'21 planning exercise, the Advanced Accelerator Concepts community proposed developing multi-TeV linear colliders and considered beam-beam effects for these machines. Such colliders operate under a high disruption regime with an enormous number of electron-positron pairs produced from QED effects. Thus, it requires a self-consistent treatment of the fields produced by the pairs, which is not implemented in state-of-the-art beam-beam codes such as GUINEA-PIG. WarpX is a parallel, open-source, and portable particle-in-cell code with an active developer community that models QED processes with photon and pair generation in relativistic laser-beam interactions. However, its application to beam-beam collisions has yet to be fully explored. In this work, we benchmark the luminosity spectra, photon spectra, and coherent production process from WarpX against GUINEA-PIG in the ILC and ultra-tight collision scenarios. Our performance comparison demonstrates a significant speed-up advantage of WarpX, ensuring a more robust and efficient modeling of electron-positron collisions at multi-TeV energies.
Accelerator Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly compares the performance of two software, WarpX and GUINEA-PIG, in simulating electron-positron collisions. WarpX is an advanced and open-source particle simulation code that can handle quantum electrodynamics (QED) processes such as photon and pair production. On the other hand, although GUINEA-PIG is widely used for beam-beam interaction studies, it lacks self-consistent treatment of pair production and modern optimizations. The paper demonstrates the significant advantage in speed of WarpX by comparing the luminosity spectra, photon spectra, and coherent pair production between the two software in the scenarios of International Linear Collider (ILC) and ultra-tight beam collisions. This makes WarpX more efficient and reliable in simulating electron-positron collisions at multi-TeV energies. Future work may involve benchmarking the pair production process, which will be implemented in WarpX, and comparing other physical outputs.