Abstract:We study the classic divide-and-choose method for equitably allocating divisible goods between two players who are rational, self-interested Bayesian agents. The players have additive values for the goods. The prior distributions on those values are common knowledge. We consider both the cases of independent values and values that are correlated across players (as occurs when there is a common-value component). We describe the structure of optimal divisions in the divide-and-choose game and identify several cases where it is possible to efficiently compute equilibria. An approximation algorithm is presented for the case when the distribution over the chooser's value for each good follows a normal distribution, along with a randomized approximation algorithm for the case of uniform distributions over intervals. A mixture of analytic results and computational simulations illuminates several striking differences between optimal strategies in the cases of known versus unknown preferences. Most notably, given unknown preferences, the divider has a compelling "diversification" incentive in creating the chooser's two options. This incentive leads to multiple goods being divided at equilibrium, quite contrary to the divider's optimal strategy when preferences are known. In many contexts, such as buy-and-sell provisions between partners, or in judging fairness, it is important to assess the relative expected utilities of the divider and chooser. Those utilities, we show, depend on the players' levels of knowledge about each other's values, the correlations between the players' values, and the number of goods being divided. Under fairly mild assumptions, we show that the chooser is strictly better off for a small number of goods, while the divider is strictly better off for a large number of goods.

Identifying Heterogeneous Decision Rules From Choices When Menus Are Unobserved

Improving Robust Decisions with Data

Heterogeneous Choice Sets and Preferences

Entangled vs. Separable Choice

Robust Decisions for Heterogeneous Agents via Certainty Equivalents

Discrete Choice under Risk with Limited Consideration

Inferring Risk Perceptions and Preferences Using Choice from Insurance Menus: Theory and Evidence

Identification and Estimation of Discrete Choice Models with Unobserved Choice Sets

Learning under Selective Labels with Data from Heterogeneous Decision-makers: An Instrumental Variable Approach

Decision Theory for Treatment Choice Problems with Partial Identification

Choosing to Rank

Playing Divide-and-Choose Given Uncertain Preferences

The Power of Simple Menus in Robust Selling Mechanisms

Robust Data-Driven Decisions Under Model Uncertainty

Distributionally robust optimization with decision dependent ambiguity sets

Predicting Choice from Information Costs

Making the Cut: Modeling and Analyzing Choice Set Restriction in Scanner Panel Data

Revealed Information

Robust and Heterogenous Odds Ratio: Estimating Price Sensitivity for Unbought Items

Identification And Statistical Decision Theory

Choice Models and Permutation Invariance: Demand Estimation in Differentiated Products Markets