Unearthing the intersections: positivity bounds, weak gravity conjecture, and asymptotic safety landscapes from photon-graviton flows

Benjamin Knorr,Alessia Platania

2024-08-10

Abstract:We compute the asymptotic safety landscape stemming from ultraviolet-complete photon-graviton flows in a field theoretic setup, and we confront it with the weak gravity conjecture and, for the first time, with positivity bounds. At fourth order in derivatives, we find two gravitational fixed points providing viable ultraviolet completions for the theory. One of them comes with a single relevant direction, which sets the scale of quantum gravity. The corresponding sub-landscape is a single point. The second fixed point yields a richer sub-landscape of effective theories, most of which is described by an approximately straight line in the space of dimensionless Wilson coefficients. We additionally discover that: (i) the two sub-landscapes are continuously connected via a small "candy cane" regime, and the whole asymptotic safety landscape falls onto a plane; this is consistent with earlier findings and could be a universal feature in Asymptotic Safety; (ii) in such a field-theoretic setup, the Euler coupling plays a special role, as it is unconstrained by quantum scale invariance, but can enter off-shell bounds such as entropy-based positivity constraints; (iii) Planck-scale-suppressed violations of both weak gravity and positivity bounds occur across the landscape. The latter result resonates with expectations grounded on effective field theory arguments.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the behavior of quantum gravity theory in the ultraviolet (UV) limit and connect it with effective field theory (EFT). Specifically, the study focuses on the photon-graviton system and, under the fourth-order derivative expansion, calculates the asymptotic safety (AS) landscape using a non-perturbative renormalization group (RG) method. Additionally, the paper compares this AS landscape with positivity bounds and the weak gravity conjecture (WGC) for the first time.

The main contributions of the paper include:

1. **Calculation of the Asymptotic Safety Landscape**: The researchers determined two viable UV fixed points by calculating the photon-graviton flow under the fourth-order derivative expansion. These two fixed points provide UV completeness for the theory. One of the fixed points has only one relevant direction, thus setting the scale for quantum gravity; the other fixed point generates a richer landscape, most of which can be approximately described as a straight line in the dimensionless Wilson coefficient space.

2. **Continuous Connection Between Landscapes**: The study found a continuous "candy cane" region between these two sub-landscapes, placing the entire asymptotic safety landscape on a plane. This finding is consistent with previous discoveries and may be a general characteristic.

3. **Comparison with Positivity Bounds and Weak Gravity Conjecture**: The research also explored the relationship between these asymptotic safety landscapes and positivity bounds and the weak gravity conjecture. The results show that throughout the landscape, there are violations of weak gravity and positivity bounds suppressed by the Planck scale. These violations are somewhat consistent with the expectations of effective field theory.

In summary, the paper attempts to understand the behavior of quantum gravity theory at extremely short distance scales through the asymptotic safety approach and combines it with concepts such as effective field theory, positivity bounds, and the weak gravity conjecture, providing a new perspective for the study of quantum gravity theory.