Constraints on primordial lepton asymmetries with full neutrino transport

Julien Froustey,Cyril Pitrou

2024-05-10

Abstract:Primordial neutrino-antineutrino asymmetries can be constrained through big-bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) relic abundances and cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies, both observables being sensitive to neutrino properties. The latter constraint, which is due to gravitational effects from all neutrino flavors, is very minute since it is at least quadratic in the asymmetries. On the contrary, the constraints from primordial abundances presently dominate, although these abundances are almost only sensitive to the electron flavor asymmetry. It is generally assumed that neutrino asymmetries are sufficiently averaged by flavor oscillations prior to BBN, which allows to constrain a common primordial neutrino asymmetry at the epoch of BBN. This simplified approach suffers two caveats that we deal with in this article, combining a neutrino evolution code and BBN calculation throughout the MeV era. First, flavor "equilibration" is not true in general, therefore an accurate dynamical evolution of asymmetries is needed to connect experimental observables to the primordial asymmetries. Second, the approximate averaging of asymmetries through flavor oscillations is associated to a reheating of the primordial plasma. It is therefore crucial to correctly describe the interplay between flavor equilibration and neutrino decoupling, as an energy redistribution prior to decoupling does not significantly alter the final effective number of neutrino species' value. Overall, we find that the space of allowed initial asymmetries is generically unbound when using currently available primordial abundances and CMB measurements. We forecast constraints using future CMB experiment capabilities, which should reverse this experimental misfortune.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the constraint problem regarding the neutrino - antineutrino asymmetry in the early universe. Specifically, researchers hope to constrain the primordial lepton asymmetry through the abundances of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) relics and the anisotropies of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). These observations are sensitive to neutrino properties, especially more sensitive to the electron - flavor asymmetry.

### Core Problems of the Paper
1. **Constraints on Primordial Lepton Asymmetry**:
- Constrain the primordial lepton asymmetry through the abundances of BBN relics and the anisotropies of CMB.
- Current constraints mainly come from the abundances of BBN relics because these abundances are particularly sensitive to the electron - flavor asymmetry.
- The constraints from CMB anisotropies are weaker because such constraints are proportional to the square of the asymmetry and have less impact.

2. **Influence of Flavor Oscillations**:
- Flavor oscillations are generally considered to average out the asymmetries of different flavors before BBN, but this simplified method has two main problems:
- Flavor "equilibrium" does not always hold, so precise dynamical evolution is required to connect experimental observables with primordial asymmetry.
- The approximate averaging of flavor oscillations will lead to the reheating of the primordial plasma, which is very important when describing the interaction between flavor equilibrium and neutrino decoupling.

3. **Prospects for Future Experiments**:
- Using current primordial abundances and CMB measurement results, the allowed initial asymmetry space is usually unbounded.
- It is predicted that the capabilities of future CMB experiments will be able to reverse this experimental misfortune and provide more stringent constraints.

### Main Methods and Results
- **Numerical Simulation**:
- Combine the neutrino evolution code and BBN calculations to study the neutrino dynamics in the MeV era.
- Simulate the evolution process of neutrinos through Quantum Kinetic Equations (QKEs), taking into account effects such as flavor oscillations, collision terms, and self - interactions.

- **Results**:
- It is found that using current primordial abundances and CMB measurement results, the allowed initial asymmetry space is usually unbounded.
- It is predicted that future CMB experiments will be able to provide more stringent constraints, thereby better understanding the primordial lepton asymmetry.

### Summary
This paper explores the constraint problem of primordial lepton asymmetry through detailed numerical simulations and theoretical analyses, especially through the abundances of BBN relics and the anisotropies of CMB. The research points out that there are certain limitations in current observational data, but future CMB experiments are expected to provide more stringent constraints, further revealing the mysteries of neutrino physics in the early universe.