Abstract:If language evolved by sexual selection to display superior intelligence, then we require conversational skills, to impress other people, gain high social status, and get a mate. Conversational skills include a Theory of Mind, a sense of self, self esteem and social emotions. To be impressive, we must converse fluently and fast. The syntax of an utterance is defined by fast unification of feature structures. The pragmatic skills of conversation are also learned and deployed as feature structures; we rehearse conversations as verbal thoughts. Many aspects of our mental lives (such as our Theory of Mind, and our social emotions) work by fast, pre conscious unification of learned feature structures, rather than rational deliberation. As we think, we use the Fast Theory of Mind to infer (unreliably) how a Shadow Audience will regard what we think, say, and do. These forces, which determine our motivations and actions, are less rational and deliberate than we like to suppose

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper explores language and its role in human rationality, primarily attempting to address the following key issues: 1. **The Nature of Language**: The author distinguishes between "narrow language" (i.e., grammar and semantics) and "broad language." Narrow language focuses on the sounds and meanings of words, while broad language encompasses the practicality of dialogue, the Theory of Mind, self-esteem, and social emotions. 2. **The Evolution of Language**: Sexual selection explains the uniqueness of language and its extraordinary speed and expressive ability. Sexual selection not only facilitated the development of language but also came with some disadvantages, such as high energy costs. 3. **The Relationship Between Language and Intelligence**: To demonstrate intelligence and attract mates, language needs to be accompanied by a high level of general intelligence. Additionally, language must be fast, expressive, and capable of understanding the thoughts and intentions of others (Theory of Mind) as well as non-verbal signals. 4. **Computational Models of Language Processing**: The paper introduces a computational model of language processing based on the unification of feature structures, a fast and powerful pattern-matching process that supports the grammatical structure of language. This model effectively explains the conversion between meaning and sound in different languages. 5. **Practicality of Dialogue and Theory of Mind**: To engage in smooth dialogue and demonstrate intelligence, people need the ability to quickly understand the intentions of others (Theory of Mind). These skills rely on fast, unconscious pattern-matching processes. 6. **Self-Worth and Emotions**: People construct their self-image through others' perceptions of them, and this social status perception affects personal self-esteem. Emotional responses (such as unpleasant emotions) help regulate behavior in conversations to maintain or enhance personal social status. 7. **Language Games**: The practicality of dialogue is likened to a language game, where participants communicate by adding or expanding shared background information. These games reflect a spirit of cooperation, and different cultural and linguistic environments have their specific game rules. In summary, the core goal of this paper is to explore how language transcends a simple symbolic system to become a complex mechanism that influences human thinking, emotions, and social interactions. It emphasizes that language is not just a tool of rationality but is deeply rooted in human irrational emotions and social behaviors.

The Evolution of Language and Human Rationality