Wide post-common envelope binaries from Gaia: orbit validation and formation models

Natsuko Yamaguchi,Kareem El-Badry,Natalie Rees,Sahar Shahaf,Tsevi Mazeh,René Andrae

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1538-3873/ad6809

2024-08-16

Abstract:Astrometry from {\it Gaia} DR3 has enabled the discovery of a sample of 3000+ binaries containing white dwarfs (WD) and main-sequence (MS) stars in relatively wide orbits, with orbital periods $P_{\rm orb} = (100-1000)$ d. This population was not predicted by binary population synthesis models before {\it Gaia} and -- if the {\it Gaia} orbits are robust -- likely requires very efficient envelope ejection during common envelope evolution (CEE). To assess the reliability of the {\it Gaia} solutions, we measured multi-epoch radial velocities (RVs) of 31 WD+MS binary candidates with $P_{\rm orb} = (40-300)$ d and \texttt{AstroSpectroSB1} orbital solutions. We jointly fit the RVs and astrometry, allowing us to validate the {\it Gaia} solutions and tighten constraints on component masses. We find a high success rate for the {\it Gaia} solutions, with only 2 out of the 31 systems showing significant discrepancies between their {\it Gaia} orbital solutions and our RVs. Joint fitting of RVs and astrometry allows us to directly constrain the secondary-to-primary flux ratio $S$, and we find $S\lesssim 0.02$ for most objects, confirming the companions are indeed WDs. We tighten constraints on the binaries' eccentricities, finding a median $e\approx 0.1$. These eccentricities are much lower than those of normal MS+MS binaries at similar periods, but much higher than predicted for binaries formed via stable mass transfer. We present MESA single and binary evolution models to explore how the binaries may have formed. The orbits of most binaries in the sample can be produced through CEE that begins when the WD progenitor is an AGB star, corresponding to initial separations of $2-5$ au. Roughly 50\% of all post-common envelope binaries are predicted to have first interacted on the AGB, ending up in wide orbits like these systems.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper mainly tries to solve the following key problems:

1. **Verify the reliability of Gaia's orbital solutions**:
- The paper evaluates the reliability of Gaia's orbital solutions by measuring the multi - epoch radial velocities (RV) of 31 white dwarf (WD) and main - sequence star (MS) binary candidates and jointly fitting these RV data with Gaia's astrometric data. This is because these wide - orbit binary samples discovered in Gaia DR3 were not previously predicted by binary star system synthesis models. If Gaia's orbital solutions are reliable, then these binaries may require very efficient envelope ejection during the common envelope evolution (CEE) process.

2. **Determine the physical parameters of binary systems**:
- By jointly fitting RV and astrometric data, the paper aims to more precisely constrain parameters such as the masses and eccentricities of binary systems. In particular, by directly constraining the flux ratio \( S \) of the secondary to the primary star, it is confirmed that the companion star is indeed a white dwarf.

3. **Explore the formation mechanisms of binary stars**:
- The paper uses MESA single - star and binary - star evolution models to explore how these binary stars are formed. Specifically, the paper studies whether these binary stars can be formed through common envelope evolution (starting when the WD precursor is an asymptotic giant branch star) or a stable mass - transfer process.

4. **Understand the characteristics of wide - orbit binary stars**:
- These binary stars have relatively long orbital periods (100 - 1000 days), and their eccentricities are much lower than those of normal MS+MS binary stars with similar periods, but higher than those of binary stars formed through stable mass - transfer. The paper attempts to explain these special orbital characteristics.

### Solutions to specific problems

1. **RV measurement and joint fitting**:
- The paper carried out multi - epoch RV measurements on 31 WD+MS binary candidates and jointly fitted these RV data with Gaia's astrometric data to verify the reliability of Gaia's orbital solutions and constrain the parameters of binary systems.

2. **Direct constraint of flux ratio**:
- By jointly fitting RV and astrometric data, the paper directly constrained the flux ratio \( S \) of the secondary to the primary star and found that \( S\leq0.02 \) for most objects, confirming that the companion star is indeed a white dwarf.

3. **Application of MESA models**:
- The paper used MESA models to test the binary - star formation channels formed through common envelope evolution and stable mass - transfer to explain the formation mechanisms of these wide - orbit binary stars.

4. **Sample selection and property analysis**:
- The paper selected 31 WD+MS binary candidates with orbital periods less than 300 days for subsequent spectral observations and analyzed in detail the properties of these binary stars, including their orbital periods, eccentricities, and flux ratios.

### Conclusions

Through the above methods, the paper successfully verified the high success rate of Gaia's orbital solutions and provided more precise physical parameter constraints for these wide - orbit binary - star systems. At the same time, the paper proposed the mechanism by which these binary stars may be formed through common envelope evolution, providing new insights for understanding the formation and evolution of this type of binary stars.