Abstract:In recent years, simulation methods based on the scaling of atomic potential functions, such as quasi-coarse-grained dynamics and coarse-grained dynamics, have shown promising results for modeling crystalline systems at multiple scales. However, this letter presents evidence suggesting that the spatiotemporal trajectories of coarse-grained systems generated by such simulation methods exhibit a complete correspondence with those of specific molecular dynamics systems. In essence, current coarse-grained simulation methods involve a direct amplification of the results obtained from molecular dynamics simulations across spatial and temporal scales, yet they may lack the capability to adequately capture authentic scale effects. Consequently, the findings of related studies warrant careful re-evaluation. Furthermore, this study underscores the importance of not only verifying the consistency of mesoscale simulation methods with microscopic simulations but also meticulously assessing their capability to accurately forecast mesoscale physical phenomena.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper The paper attempts to address the effectiveness and reliability of the Quasi-coarse-grained dynamics (QCGD) method in simulating the mesoscopic behavior of crystalline materials. Specifically, the authors explore the equivalence between the QCGD method and full-atom Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations through theoretical analysis and experimental validation, pointing out that the spatial and temporal scaling in the QCGD method cannot truly capture mesoscopic physical phenomena. ### Summary of Main Content 1. **Background Introduction**: - Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations are crucial in materials science and engineering, but they face two main challenges: the accuracy of the simulation results depends on the interatomic potential functions, and the computational resource demand is enormous. - To address these challenges, various mesoscopic simulation methods have been developed in recent years, such as Quasi-coarse-grained dynamics (QCGD) and Coarse-grained Molecular Dynamics (CGMD). These methods simulate the mesoscopic behavior of crystalline systems by scaling the atomic potential functions. 2. **Theoretical Analysis**: - The authors mathematically demonstrate the complete correspondence between the QCGD method and full-atom MD simulations in terms of spatiotemporal trajectories. Specifically, the behavior of representative particles (R-particles) in the QCGD method can be fully described by the behavior of the corresponding full-atom system. - This implies that the QCGD method is equivalent to MD simulations at any scale and cannot capture true mesoscopic effects by increasing the level of coarse-graining. 3. **Experimental Validation**: - The authors further validate the theoretical analysis through simulation experiments of uniaxial compression of polycrystalline copper and impact loading of polycrystalline aluminum. The results show that the QCGD simulation results at different levels of coarse-graining are highly consistent with full-atom MD simulation results but do not reflect the true mesoscopic scale effects. 4. **Conclusion**: - The authors conclude that the QCGD method based on scaling atomic potential functions does not fundamentally differ in computational results from MD simulations with the same number of particles. Therefore, adjusting the level of coarse-graining to study mesoscopic effects is not feasible. - Although the QCGD method has been widely applied in various studies, its results do not have actual physical significance. For crystalline systems such as metallic materials, there is currently no mesoscopic simulation method that can naturally describe the evolution behavior of microstructures. - The authors suggest that while verifying the consistency of mesoscopic simulation methods with full-atom simulation results, it is also necessary to carefully evaluate these methods' ability to accurately capture mesoscopic physical phenomena. ### Summary Through theoretical analysis and experimental validation, the paper reveals the limitations of the QCGD method in simulating the mesoscopic behavior of crystalline materials, emphasizing the need for more refined evaluation of mesoscopic simulation methods' ability to capture real physical phenomena. This finding has significant guiding implications for research in related fields.

Equivalence analysis between Quasi-coarse-grained and Atomistic Simulations

Resolving the Dynamic Properties of Entangled Linear Polymers in Non-Equilibrium Coarse Grain Simulation with a Priori Scaling Factors.

Learning Effective Molecular Models from Experimental Observables.

Dynamical Properties of Coarse-Grained Linear SDEs

Nonadiabatic Dynamics Via the Symmetrical Quasi-Classical Method in the Presence of Anharmonicity.

Ab Initio Validation on the Connection Between Atomistic and Hydrodynamic Description to Unravel the Ion Dynamics of Warm Dense Matter

A consistency study of coarse-grained dynamical chains through a nonlinear wave equation of mixed type

Thermal conductivity prediction by atomistic simulation methods: Recent advances and detailed comparison

Large Scale and Quantum Accurate Molecular Dynamics Simulation:Liquid Iron under Extreme Condition

A Hybrid Molecular Dynamics/Atomic-Scale Finite Element Method for Quasi-Static Atomistic Simulations at Finite Temperature

Quantum theory of multiscale coarse-graining

An Atomistic Simulation Method Combining Molecular Dynamics with Finite Element Technique

An Adaptive Finite Element Approach to Atomic-Scale Mechanics - The Quasicontinuum Method

The Atom Sampling Method for Mesoscale Molecular Dynamics and Its Application to Graphene Assemblies.

Data-driven dynamical coarse-graining for condensed matter systems

Towards a priori uncertainty quantification in coarse-grained molecular dynamics: Generalized multipole potentials.

Atomistic Computer Simulation of Fracture Process at Nanoscale

Atom Sampling method for mesoscale molecular dynamics and its application to graphene assemblies

The Planck Telescope