Behavioral analysis in immersive learning environments: A systematic literature review and research agenda

Yu Liu,Kang Yue,Yue Liu

2024-05-06

Abstract:The rapid growth of immersive technologies in educational areas has increased research interest in analyzing the specific behavioral patterns of learners in immersive learning environments. Considering the fact that research on the technical affordances of immersive technologies and the pedagogical affordances of behavioral analysis remains fragmented, this study first contributes by developing a conceptual framework that amalgamates learning requirements, specification, evaluation, and iteration into an integrated model to identify learning benefits and potential hurdles of behavioral analysis in immersive learning environments. Then, a systematic review was conducted underpinning the proposed conceptual framework to retrieve valuable empirical evidence from the 40 eligible articles during the last decade. The review findings suggest that (1) there is an essential need to sufficiently prepare the salient pedagogical requirements to define the specific learning stage, envisage intended cognitive objectives, and specify an appropriate set of learning activities, when developing comprehensive plans on behavioral analysis in immersive learning environments. (2) Researchers could customize the unique immersive experimental implementation by considering factors from four dimensions: learner, pedagogy, context, and representation. (3) The behavioral patterns constructed in immersive learning environments vary by considering the influence of behavioral analysis techniques, research themes, and immersive technical features. (4) The use of behavioral analysis in immersive learning environments faces several challenges from technical, implementation, and data processing perspectives. This study also articulates critical research agenda that could drive future investigation on behavioral analysis in immersive learning environments.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how to identify and understand learners' behavior patterns through behavior analysis techniques in immersive learning environments. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Clarifying Educational Needs**: When designing behavior analysis in immersive learning environments, it is essential to fully prepare important educational needs, define specific learning stages, envision expected cognitive goals, and specify appropriate learning activities.

2. **Customizing Experimental Implementation**: Researchers can customize unique immersive experimental implementation methods based on four dimensions (learner, pedagogy, context, representation).

3. **Diversity of Behavior Patterns**: The behavior patterns constructed in immersive learning environments will vary depending on the behavior analysis techniques, research topics, and characteristics of immersive technologies.

4. **Challenges Faced**: From the perspectives of technology, implementation, and data processing, there are multiple challenges in using behavior analysis techniques in immersive learning environments.

To systematically address these issues, the paper proposes a conceptual framework that integrates learning needs, norms, assessment, and iteration into a comprehensive model to identify the potential advantages and obstacles of behavior analysis in immersive learning environments. Additionally, the paper conducts a systematic literature review to extract valuable empirical evidence from 40 related articles over the past 10 years, thereby providing guidance for future research.