Updating neutrino mass constraints with Background measurements

Deng Wang,Olga Mena,Eleonora Di Valentino,Stefano Gariazzo

2024-05-06

Abstract:Low-redshift probes, such as Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) and Supernovae Ia luminosity distances, have been shown to be crucial for improving the bounds on the total neutrino mass from cosmological observations, due to their ability to break degeneracies among the different parameters. Here, we expand background observations to include $H(z)$ measurements from cosmic chronometers, distance moduli from Gamma Ray Bursts (GRBs), and angular diameter distances from galaxy clusters. For the very first time, we find neutrino mass limits below the minimal expectations from neutrino oscillation probes, suggesting non-standard neutrino and/or cosmological scenarios. The tightening of the neutrino mass bound is due to the slightly higher value of the Hubble constant $H_0$ preferred by the former three background probes, and also due to the improved errors on $H_0$ and the matter mass-energy density $\Omega_{\rm m}$. All values of $H_0$ are however in agreement at the $1-2\sigma$ level. Interestingly, it is not only the combination of the three background probes that is responsible for the $\sum m_\nu <0.06$~eV limits, but also each of them independently. The tightest bound we find here is $\sum m_\nu<0.043$~eV at $2\sigma$ after combining Cosmic Microwave Background Planck data with DESI BAO, Supernovae Ia, GRBs, cosmic chronometers, and galaxy clusters, showing a clear tension between neutrino oscillation results and cosmological analyses. In general, removing either one of the two background probes still provides a limit $\sum m_\nu \lesssim 0.06$~eV, reassuring the enormous potential of these low-redshift observations in constraining the neutrino mass.

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to further constrain the total neutrino mass (\(\sum m_\nu\)) by combining new background observational data. Specifically, the author utilizes data from various low - redshift detection means such as the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB), baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO), type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), gamma - ray bursts (GRBs), cosmic chronometers, and angular diameter distances from galaxy clusters to improve the constraints on the total neutrino mass.

### Main problems
1. **Improving neutrino mass constraints**: Existing neutrino oscillation experiments provide evidence for the existence of neutrino mass, but cannot directly measure the neutrino mass. Cosmological observations can provide independent and more stringent neutrino mass constraints. This paper aims to further tighten these constraints by introducing more types of background observational data.

2. **Resolving the tension between neutrino mass and cosmological parameters**: Current cosmological observations have already shown possible consistency problems with the results of neutrino oscillation experiments. For example, the lower limit of the neutrino mass obtained from cosmological observations is already lower than the minimum value expected from neutrino oscillation experiments. This indicates that there may be non - standard neutrino physics or cosmological scenarios.

### Research methods
- **Dataset integration**: The author integrates multiple different observational datasets, including:
- **CMB**: Temperature, polarization, and lensing effect observations from the Planck satellite.
- **BAO**: BAO measurements from the SDSS and DESI surveys.
- **SNe Ia**: Luminosity distances of type Ia supernovae from the Pantheon + sample.
- **GRBs**: Distance moduli from gamma - ray bursts.
- **Cosmic chronometers**: Based on the age changes of the oldest and passively evolving galaxies.
- **Angular diameter distances from galaxy clusters**: Based on observations from the Chandra and XMM - Newton telescopes.

- **Theoretical calculation**: Use the CAMB Boltzmann solver to calculate the theoretical power spectrum, and perform Bayesian analysis through CosmoMC to infer the posterior distribution of model parameters.

### Key findings
- **More stringent neutrino mass constraints**: By combining various background observational data, especially GRBs and angular diameter distances from galaxy clusters, the author obtains a more stringent upper limit on the neutrino mass than before. For example, in some combinations, the 95% confidence level upper limit on the total neutrino mass is 0.043 eV.

- **The influence of the Hubble constant**: A higher Hubble constant value (\(H_0\)) helps tighten the neutrino mass constraints. The background observational data tend to support a higher \(H_0\) value, thus leading to more stringent neutrino mass constraints.

- **Potential new physical phenomena**: The research results indicate that current cosmological observations may imply new physical phenomena beyond the standard model, such as non - standard neutrino interactions or dark energy physics.

In general, this paper significantly improves the constraints on neutrino mass by introducing more background observational data, and reveals the potential tension between neutrino mass and cosmological parameters, providing important clues for further exploration of new physical phenomena.