A Pilot Study on the Comparison of Prefrontal Cortex Activities of Robotic Therapies on Elderly with Mild Cognitive Impairment

King Tai Henry Au-Yeung,William Wai Lam Chan,Kwan Yin Brian Chan,Hongjie Jiang,Junpei Zhong

2024-05-04

Abstract:Demographic shifts have led to an increase in mild cognitive impairment (MCI), and this study investigates the effects of cognitive training (CT) and reminiscence therapy (RT) conducted by humans or socially assistive robots (SARs) on prefrontal cortex activation in elderly individuals with MCI, aiming to determine the most effective therapy-modality combination for promoting cognitive function. This pilot study employs a randomized control trial (RCT) design. Additionally, the study explores the efficacy of Reminiscence Therapy (RT) in comparison to Cognitive Training (CT). Eight MCI subjects, with a mean age of 70.125 years, were randomly assigned to ``human-led'' or ``SAR-led'' groups. Utilizing Functional Near-infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS) to measure oxy-hemoglobin concentration changes in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), the study found no significant differences in the effects of human-led and SAR-led cognitive training on DLPFC activation. However, distinct patterns emerged in memory encoding and retrieval phases between RT and CT, shedding light on the impacts of these interventions on brain activation in the context of MCI.

Robotics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the effects of social assistive robots (SARs) in conducting cognitive training (CT) and reminiscence therapy (RT) among the elderly with mild cognitive impairment (MCI), and compare them with human - led interventions. Specifically, the research objectives include:

1. **Compare the effects of social assistive robots (such as NAO robots) and human - led interventions on the activation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) in the elderly with MCI**:
- The study attempts to answer whether using social assistive robots for RT or CT can produce effects similar to those of human - led interventions.

2. **Explore the different effects of CT and RT on prefrontal cortex activity**:
- The study focuses on the specific pattern differences in DLPFC activation between these two therapies during the memory encoding and retrieval stages.

3. **Determine the optimal combination of "therapy type (CT/RT) × intervention method (robot/human - led)"**:
- The aim is to find out which combination is the most effective in activating the prefrontal cortex, so as to provide the best treatment plan for the elderly with MCI.

### Background information

With the aging of the population, the incidence of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is gradually increasing. MCI is manifested as a gradual decline in cognitive ability and may further develop into dementia. Current research shows that social interaction and social participation can significantly improve the cognitive function of MCI patients and reduce the risk of cognitive decline. However, due to limited human resources, traditional treatment methods are difficult to implement on a large scale. Therefore, researchers have begun to explore the use of social assistive robots as an alternative to provide more cost - effective treatment means.

### Method overview

- **Experimental design**: A randomized controlled trial (RCT) design was adopted, and 8 elderly MCI patients were randomly assigned to the "robot - led group" and the "human - led group". The changes in hemoglobin concentration in the prefrontal cortex were measured by functional near - infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) to evaluate the effects of different intervention methods on brain activation.

- **Standardization of experimental stimuli**: In order to ensure the consistency of the experiment, all story materials were standardized, maintaining the same length and content structure, and only differed in time orientation (that is, CT focused on current information, and RT focused on past information).

- **Data analysis**: Statistical methods such as independent - sample t - test, paired t - test and chi - square test were used to analyze the differences between different groups, with a focus on HbO2 changes during the memory encoding and retrieval stages.

### Main findings

1. **Comparison between robot - led and human - led interventions**:
- During the memory encoding and retrieval stages, there were no significant differences in the effects of robot - led and human - led interventions on DLPFC activation, indicating that robot - led interventions may have effects similar to those of human - led interventions.

2. **Different effects of CT and RT on DLPFC activation**:
- During the memory encoding stage of the left DLPFC, RT led to more obvious deactivation (negative HbO2 change), while during the memory retrieval stage, RT showed more obvious activation (positive HbO2 change). This indicates that there are differences in brain activation patterns between the two therapies in different cognitive tasks.

3. **Optimal combination**:
- During the memory encoding stage of the left DLPFC, human - led CT showed higher HbO2 changes than RT, indicating that in this specific task, human - led CT may be a more effective choice.

### Conclusion

This study shows that social assistive robots can replace humans to a certain extent in conducting cognitive training and reminiscence therapy, especially showing similar effects in memory retrieval tasks. However, in memory encoding tasks, human - led interventions may be more effective. These findings provide an important reference for further optimizing MCI treatment plans.