Abstract:In this paper we provide a theoretical analysis of Variable Annuities with a focus on the holder's right to an early termination of the contract. We obtain a rigorous pricing formula and the optimal exercise boundary for the surrender option. We also illustrate our theoretical results with extensive numerical experiments. The pricing problem is formulated as an optimal stopping problem with a time-dependent payoff which is discontinuous at the maturity of the contract and non-smooth. This structure leads to non-monotonic optimal stopping boundaries which we prove nevertheless to be continuous and regular in the sense of diffusions for the stopping set. The lack of monotonicity of the boundary makes it impossible to use classical methods from optimal stopping. Also more recent results about Lipschitz continuous boundaries are not applicable in our setup. Thus, we contribute a new methodology for non-monotone stopping boundaries.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the pricing and optimal exercise boundary of variable annuities (VAs) with surrender charges. Specifically, the article focuses on the right of policyholders to terminate the contract early before the contract expires (i.e., the surrender option), and provides a rigorous pricing formula and optimal exercise boundary for this right.
### Analysis of Main Problems
1. **Pricing of the Surrender Option**:
- The article models the pricing problem of variable annuities as an optimal stopping problem with time - dependent payoffs. This structure leads to a non - monotonic optimal stopping boundary, which makes the traditional optimal stopping theory methods no longer applicable.
- By introducing new mathematical methods, the author solves the continuity and regularity problems of the non - monotonic stopping boundary and derives the no - arbitrage price formula for variable annuities.
2. **Optimal Exercise Boundary**:
- The article not only provides a pricing formula but also analyzes in detail the optimal exercise boundary. This boundary determines when the policyholder should exercise the surrender option to maximize their benefits.
- Due to the existence of surrender charges, the optimal exercise boundary is not monotonically increasing but shows complex non - monotonic characteristics. Through a series of mathematical transformations and technical means, the author proves the continuity and regularity of this boundary.
### Mathematical Models and Methods
- **Geometric Brownian Motion**: Assume that the account value \( X_t \) evolves according to geometric Brownian motion, that is,
\[
dX_t = X_t \left[ (r - c) dt+\sigma dW_t \right], \quad X_0 = x_0>0,
\]
where \( r \) is the risk - free interest rate, \( c \) is the fixed cost rate of the insurance company, \( \sigma \) is the market volatility, and \( W_t \) is the standard Brownian motion.
- **Mortality Risk**: Considers the mortality risk of policyholders, defines the survival probability \( sp_{\eta + t} \), and assumes that the death time \( \tau_d \) is independent of the Brownian motion.
- **Optimal Stopping Problem**: Transforms the pricing problem into an optimal stopping problem, with the goal of finding the optimal surrender time \( \tau^* \) to maximize the expected payoff.
### Conclusions and Contributions
- **New Method**: The article proposes a brand - new method for dealing with non - monotonic optimal stopping boundaries, which is of great significance in the field of financial engineering.
- **Numerical Experiments**: Verifies the validity of the theoretical results through extensive numerical experiments and shows the huge impact of the surrender charge structure on the price of variable annuities.
- **Risk Management**: Understanding the optimal surrender decision helps insurance companies better assess and manage the risks associated with variable annuities, especially liquidity risk and surrender risk.
In conclusion, through in - depth analysis of the surrender option of variable annuities, this paper fills the gaps in the existing literature and provides valuable insights for financial market participants.