Abstract:The problem of observables and their supposed lack of change has been significant in Hamiltonian quantum gravity since the 1950s. This paper considers the unrecognized variety of ideas about observables in the thought of constrained Hamiltonian dynamics co-founder Peter Bergmann, who trained many students at Syracuse and invented observables. Whereas initially Bergmann required a constrained Hamiltonian formalism to be mathematically equivalent to the Lagrangian, in 1953 Bergmann and Schiller introduced a novel postulate, motivated by facilitating quantum gravity. This postulate held that observables were invariant under transformations generated by each individual first-class constraint. While modern works rely on Bergmann's authority and sometimes speak of "Bergmann observables," he had much to say about observables, generally interesting and plausible but not all mutually consistent and much of it neglected. On occasion he required observables to be locally defined (not changeless and global); at times he wanted observables to be independent of the Hamiltonian formalism (implicitly contrary to a definition involving separate first-class constraints). But typically he took observables to have vanishing Poisson bracket with each first-class constraint and took this result to be justified by the example of electrodynamics. He expected observables to be analogous to the transverse true degrees of freedom of electromagnetism. Given these premises, there is no coherent concept of observables which he reliably endorsed, much less established. A revised definition of observables that satisfies the requirement that equivalent theories should have equivalent observables using the Rosenfeld-Anderson-Bergmann-Castellani gauge generator G, a tuned sum of first-class constraints that changes the canonical action ∫dt(pq̇-H) by a boundary term. Bootstrapping from theory formulations with no first-class constraints, one finds that the "external" coordinate gauge symmetry of GR calls for covariance (a transformation rule and hence a 4-dimensional Lie derivative for the Poisson bracket), not invariance (0 Poisson bracket), under G (not each first-class constraint separately).

"Observables" in de Sitter Quantum Gravity: in Perturbation Theory and Beyond

De Sitter quantum gravity and the emergence of local algebras

Physics, Philosophy, Observers and Multiverses

Vacua in locally de Sitter cosmologies, and how to distinguish them

Observables in classical canonical gravity: folklore demystified

On the Impossibility of Precise Verification of Models of Quantum Gravity

Holographic Space-time, Newton's Law and the Dynamics of Black Holes

My Personal History With the Quantum Theory of de Sitter Space

Peter Bergmann on observables in Hamiltonian General Relativity: A historical-critical investigation

Do we live in an eigenstate of the "fundamental constants" operators?

Relational Observables in Gravity: a Review

Low-curvature quantum corrections from unitary evolution of de Sitter space

Observations in Quantum Cosmology

Quantum gravity of the Heisenberg algebra

Quantum Features of the Cosmological Horizon

Quantum measurement and geometry

The Quantum Vacuum of Spacetime with a Fundamental Length

Synge's World function and the quantum spacetime

Klein-Gordon particles in Gödel-type Som-Raychaudhuri cosmic string spacetime and the phenomenon of spacetime associated degeneracies

Quantum Compositeness of Gravity: Black Holes, AdS and Inflation