A new understanding on the history of developing MRI for cancer detection

Donald C. Chang
2024-06-21
Abstract:Science is about facts and truth. Yet sometimes the truth and facts are not obvious. For example, in the field of MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging), there has been a long-lasting debate about who were the major contributors in its development. Particularly, there was a strong dispute between the followers of two scientists, R. Damadian and P. Lauterbur. In this review, we carefully trace the major developments in applying NMR for cancer detection starting almost 50 years ago. The research records show that the truth was beyond the claims of either research camps. The development of NMR for cancer detection involved multiple research groups, who made critical contributions at different junctures.
Physics and Society,History and Philosophy of Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the controversy over the contributors in the development history of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in cancer detection. Specifically, the paper aims to clarify the identities of the main contributors and their specific contributions during the development of using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) technology for cancer detection. The paper mentions that for a long time, there has been a controversy in the scientific community regarding who are the main contributors to the development of MRI, especially the debate between two scientists, R. Damadian and P. Lauterbur, is particularly intense. Both Damadian and Lauterbur claim that they have made crucial contributions to the development of MRI, and this controversy has even affected the awarding of the Nobel Prize. By reviewing historical records, the paper analyzes in detail how multiple research teams gradually promoted the application of NMR technology in cancer detection starting from the 1970s. The paper points out that the application of NMR technology in cancer detection involves three key steps: 1. **Using spin - echo NMR to measure relaxation times in cellular water**: This technique can be used to measure T1 and T2 relaxation times in cellular water. 2. **Discovering that NMR relaxation times and spin - diffusion coefficients (D) are sensitive to the physiological - pathological states of biological tissues**: Changes in these parameters can reflect the health status of tissues. 3. **Using magnetic field gradients for 2D NMR scanning**: This technique makes it possible to generate 2D images, thus enabling a more intuitive observation of the structure and state of tissues. The paper emphasizes that these advances are the result of the joint efforts of multiple research teams, rather than the sole contribution of a single scientist or team. Through detailed literature review and analysis, the paper hopes to provide the scientific community with a more objective and comprehensive historical perspective to eliminate misunderstandings and controversies regarding the development history of MRI.