Abstract:Coherent sets of desirable gamble sets is used as a model for representing an agents opinions and choice preferences under uncertainty. In this paper we provide some results about the axioms required for coherence and the natural extension of a given set of desirable gamble sets. We also show that coherent sets of desirable gamble sets can be represented by a proper filter of coherent sets of desirable gambles.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses the properties of desirable gamble sets, which are a model for representing agents' opinions and preference for choices under uncertainty. The author provides some results on consistency axioms and natural extensions of given gamble sets. The core of the paper is to show how to represent desirable gamble sets through appropriate filters.
Specifically, the paper first defines gambles and admissible gambles, and then presents consistency axioms, including empty set, zero element, weak dominance, inclusiveness, dominance, and finite additivity. These axioms ensure the consistency of sets, that is, the decision logic of agents under uncertainty is coherent.
Next, the paper introduces the natural extension of gamble sets, which is an important concept that gives a method to construct larger and consistent sets from an initial set of admissible gambles. The author proves that these axioms are equivalent when gamble sets must be finite, and discusses how to extend these theories to the case of infinite sets.
The paper also explores how to relate desirable gamble sets to sets of individual gambles and how to use these gambles to represent consistent sets. The author points out that in the case of finite sets, there exists a representation corresponding to the natural extension of gamble sets.
The purpose of the entire study is to provide a set of axioms in the framework of uncertainty to better understand and describe agents' decision-making processes, especially when gamble sets may be infinite. Through these axioms and the concept of natural extension, a formal theory can be constructed to deal with complex preference problems.