Characterizing Public Debt Cycles: Don't Ignore the Impact of Financial Cycles

Tianbao Zhou,Zhixin Liu,Yingying Xu

2024-04-26

Abstract:Based on the quarterly data from 26 advanced economies (AEs) and 18 emerging market economies (EMs) over the past two decades, this paper estimates the short- and medium-term impacts of financial cycles on the duration and amplitude of public debt cycles. The results indicate that public debt expansions are larger than their contractions in duration and amplitude, aligning with the "deficit bias hypothesis" and being more pronounced in EMs than in AEs. The impacts of various financial cycles are different. Specifically, credit cycles in EMs significantly impact the duration and amplitude of public debt cycles. Notably, short- and medium-term credit booms in EMs shorten the duration of public debt contractions and reduce the amplitude. Fast credit growth in AEs prolongs the duration of public debt expansions and increases the amplitude. However, credit cycles in AEs show no significant impact. For house price cycles, the overall impact is stronger in EMs than in AEs, differing between short- and medium-term cycles. Finally, the impact of equity price cycles is significant in the short term, but not in the medium term. Equity price busts are more likely to prolong the expansion of public debt in EMs while increasing the amplitude of public debt contractions in AEs. Uncovering the impacts of multiple financial cycles on public debt cycles provides implications for better debt policies under different financial conditions.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses how financial cycles affect public debt cycles, with particular focus on the impact of financial cycles on the duration and magnitude of debt expansions and contractions. The study is based on data from the past twenty years and finds that financial cycles, such as credit cycles, housing cycles, and stock market cycles, have significant effects on public debt in different economies. For example, credit booms shorten the duration of debt contractions in emerging market economies, while credit growth extends the duration of debt expansions in advanced economies. In addition, asset price fluctuations also affect public debt levels, such as the booms and busts in housing prices and stock markets. The paper emphasizes the importance of formulating debt policies under different financial conditions and highlights the differences in the impact of financial cycles on public debt cycles in advanced economies and emerging market economies.