Agentive Permissions in Multiagent Systems

Qi Shi
2024-04-26
Abstract:This paper proposes to distinguish four forms of agentive permissions in multiagent settings. The main technical results are the complexity analysis of model checking, the semantic undefinability of modalities that capture these forms of permissions through each other, and a complete logical system capturing the interplay between these modalities.
Artificial Intelligence,Multiagent Systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper discusses four forms of agent permissions in multi-agent systems. The focus is on ensuring and admitting different types of agent permissions in multi-agent or non-deterministic environments, where the behavior of one agent can be influenced by the behavior of other agents or uncertainties. The difference between ensuring and admitting lies in that ensuring represents a behavior that guarantees a certain result, while admitting indicates that a behavior may allow a certain result to occur but does not guarantee it. The author proposes a formal semantics to describe the corresponding modes of these four permissions and analyzes the complexity of model checking. It is proved that these modes cannot be semantically defined by each other. A complete logical system is provided to capture the interactions between these modes. The paper also discusses strong permission and weak permission, where the former allows an agent to take any action that satisfies certain conditions, and the latter expresses the capability of an agent to achieve a certain state through permitted actions. The main contributions of the paper include: 1. Proposing a formal semantics for the four permissions in a multi-agent setting. 2. Analyzing the model checking problem and simplifying it to STIT logic and ATL (Alternating-Time Temporal Logic). 3. Proving the semantic indefinability between these modes and providing a complete logical system for the four modes. In addition, the paper reviews the history of agent logic and obligation logic in the literature, discusses the concepts of weak and strong permissions, and their differences in single-agent and multi-agent environments. The paper concludes with the proposal of formal grammar and semantics, as well as the proof of completeness and consistency of the logical system.