Abstract:Synchronization of coupled oscillators is a fundamental process in both natural and artificial networks. While much work has investigated the asymptotic stability of the synchronous solution, the fundamental question of the transient behavior toward synchronization has received far less attention. In this work, we present the transverse reactivity as a metric to quantify the instantaneous rate of growth or decay of desynchronizing perturbations. We first use the transverse reactivity to design a coupling-efficient and energy-efficient synchronization strategy that involves varying the coupling strength dynamically according to the current state of the system. We find that our synchronization strategy is able to synchronize networks in both simulation and experiment over a significantly larger (often by orders of magnitude) range of coupling strengths than is possible when the coupling strength is constant. Then, we characterize the effects of network topology on the transient dynamics towards synchronization by introducing the concept of network syncreactivity: A network with a larger syncreactivity has a larger transverse reactivity at every point on the synchronization manifold, independent of the oscillator dynamics. We classify real-world examples of complex networks in terms of their syncreactivity.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the efficiency of transient behavior in synchronization dynamics (i.e., the process of the system transitioning to the synchronized state). Specifically, the paper focuses on how to design a coupling strategy to enable the network to achieve synchronization at a lower average coupling strength and consume less energy in this process. The paper proposes the metric of "transverse reactivity" to quantify the immediate growth rate or decay rate of asynchronous perturbations. Based on this concept, the authors develop a method for dynamically adjusting the coupling strength, known as the "Coupling When Needed (CWN)" strategy. This method can not only significantly expand the range of coupling strengths at which synchronization occurs but also reduce the energy required to achieve synchronization. ### Main Research Questions 1. **Transient Behavior in Synchronization Dynamics**: Compared with the large number of existing studies on the asymptotic stability of synchronization solutions, relatively few studies have been conducted on transient behavior. The paper attempts to fill this gap and explore how to effectively evaluate and control the process of the network transitioning to the synchronized state. 2. **Design of Coupling Strategy**: A new coupling strategy is proposed to improve synchronization efficiency by dynamically adjusting the coupling strength, reducing the required coupling strength and synchronization energy. 3. **Impact of Network Topology on Synchronization**: The concept of "network syncreactivity" is introduced to characterize the impact of network topology on the transient behavior of synchronization. ### Solutions 1. **Transverse Reactivity**: Define transverse reactivity \( r(\mathbf{x}_s) \) to measure the immediate growth rate or decay rate of asynchronous perturbations. The formula is as follows: \[ r(\mathbf{x}_s) = e_1\left( \frac{\mathbf{D}F(\mathbf{x}_s) + \mathbf{D}F^\top(\mathbf{x}_s)}{2} + \sigma \xi \mathbf{H} \right) \] where \( e_1(\cdot) \) calculates the maximum eigenvalue, \( \mathbf{D}F(\mathbf{x}_s) \) is the Jacobian matrix of \( F \) at \( \mathbf{x}_s \), and \( \xi \) is the algebraic connectivity, defined as: \[ \xi = e_1\left( \frac{\mathbf{V}^\top \mathbf{L} + \mathbf{L}^\top \mathbf{V}}{2} \right) \] 2. **Coupling When Needed Strategy**: Dynamically adjust the coupling strength according to transverse reactivity. The specific strategy is as follows: - For the transition from asynchronous to synchronous (A → S): \[ \sigma(t) = \begin{cases} \bar{\sigma} \frac{1 - \gamma (1 - \tau)}{\tau}, & r(\bar{\mathbf{x}}(t)) > \beta \\ \bar{\sigma} \gamma, & r(\bar{\mathbf{x}}(t)) \leq \beta \end{cases} \] - For the transition from synchronous to asynchronous (S → A): \[ \sigma(t) = \begin{cases} \bar{\sigma} \alpha, & r(\bar{\mathbf{x}}(t)) > \beta \\ \bar{\sigma} \frac{1 - \tau \alpha}{1 - \tau}, & r(\bar{\mathbf{x}}(t)) \leq \beta \end{cases} \] 3. **Experimental Verification**: The Coupling When Needed is verified through numerical simulation and experiments.

The Efficiency of Synchronization Dynamics and the Role of Network Syncreactivity