Abstract:Precision medicine aims to tailor treatment decisions according to patients' characteristics. G-estimation and dynamic weighted ordinary least squares (dWOLS) are double robust statistical methods that can be used to identify optimal adaptive treatment strategies. They require both a model for the outcome and a model for the treatment and are consistent if at least one of these models is correctly specified. It is underappreciated that these methods additionally require modeling all existing treatment-confounder interactions to yield consistent estimators. Identifying partially adaptive treatment strategies that tailor treatments according to only a few covariates, ignoring some interactions, may be preferable in practice. It has been proposed to combine inverse probability weighting and G-estimation to address this issue, but we argue that the resulting estimator is not expected to be double robust. Building on G-estimation and dWOLS, we propose alternative estimators of partially adaptive strategies and demonstrate their double robustness. We investigate and compare the empirical performance of six estimators in a simulation study. As expected, estimators combining inverse probability weighting with either G-estimation or dWOLS are biased when the treatment model is incorrectly specified. The other estimators are unbiased if either the treatment or the outcome model are correctly specified and have similar standard errors. Using data maintained by the Centre des Maladies du Sein, the methods are illustrated to estimate a partially adaptive treatment strategy for tailoring hormonal therapy use in breast cancer patients according to their estrogen receptor status and body mass index. R software implementing our estimators is provided.

Double Robust Variance Estimation

Multiple Robustness Estimation in Causal Inference

Relaxed Doubly Robust Estimation in Causal Inference

Multiply robust estimation of marginal structural models in observational studies subject to covariate-driven observations

Double robust estimation of partially adaptive treatment strategies

An Alternative Doubly Robust Estimation in Causal Inference Model

Statistical Inference for Data-adaptive Doubly Robust Estimators with Survival Outcomes

Doubly Robust Estimation in Causal Inference with Missing Outcomes: with an Application to the Aerobics Center Longitudinal Study

On Doubly Robust Estimation with Nonignorable Missing Data Using Instrumental Variables

Doubly Robust Nonparametric Instrumental Variable Estimators for Survival Outcomes

Doubly robust treatment effect estimation with missing attributes

Doubly robust estimation for conditional treatment effect: a study on asymptotics

A Stable and More Efficient Doubly Robust Estimator

The Bias-Variance Tradeoff of Doubly Robust Estimator with Targeted $L_1$ regularized Neural Networks Predictions

Efficient Generalization and Transportation

Doubly Robust Augmented-Estimating-equations Estimation with Nonignorable Nonresponse Data

Enhanced doubly robust estimation with concave link functions for estimands in clinical trials

Benchmarking Estimators for Natural Experiments: A Novel Dataset and a Doubly Robust Algorithm

Robust weights that optimally balance confounders for estimating marginal hazard ratios

Doubly robust estimation of optimal treatment regimes for survival data using an instrumental variable

Ensemble and Calibration Multiply Robust Estimation for Quantile Treatment Effect.