Saving proof-of-work by hierarchical block structure

Valdemar Melicher
2024-04-23
Abstract:We argue that the current POW based consensus algorithm of the Bitcoin network suffers from a fundamental economic discrepancy between the real world transaction (txn) costs incurred by miners and the wealth that is being transacted. Put simply, whether one transacts 1 satoshi or 1 bitcoin, the same amount of electricity is needed when including this txn into a block. The notorious Bitcoin blockchain problems such as its high energy usage per txn or its scalability issues are, either partially or fully, mere consequences of this fundamental economic inconsistency. We propose making the computational cost of securing the txns proportional to the wealth being transferred, at least temporarily.
Numerical Analysis,Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science,Cryptography and Security,Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the fundamental economic inconsistency problems in the Proof of Work (PoW) consensus algorithm in the Bitcoin network. Specifically, the current PoW mechanism has led to the following problems: 1. **Mismatch between transaction cost and transaction value**: Whether the transaction amount is 1 satoshi or 1 bitcoin, miners consume the same amount of electricity when including the transaction in a block. This results in overly high costs for small - value transactions, while the security of large - value transactions does not improve correspondingly. 2. **High energy consumption and scalability issues**: The high energy consumption per transaction in the Bitcoin blockchain and its scalability issues are all partial or total consequences of this economic inconsistency. To solve these problems, the paper proposes a new method to make the computational cost proportional to the transaction amount, at least temporarily. Specific measures include: - Introducing a simple incentive - based Bitcoin security model. - Adding two parameters to each transaction, one controlling the time used to protect this transaction, and the other determining the part of the network used to complete this transaction. - Proposing a series of Hierarchical Block Structures (HBSs), which contain transactions with the above - mentioned parameters. In this way, different levels of trust can be achieved, and network fees and energy use can be matched. In addition, the paper also proposes a homotopy - based transition mechanism to introduce new HBSs into the existing blockchain in a relatively safe and continuous manner. In summary, this paper aims to solve the economically irrational problems in Bitcoin's Proof of Work mechanism, thereby enhancing its feasibility and efficiency as a payment system.