Evidence for eccentricity in the population of binary black holes observed by LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA

Nihar Gupte,Antoni Ramos-Buades,Alessandra Buonanno,Jonathan Gair,M. Coleman Miller,Maximilian Dax,Stephen R. Green,Michael Pürrer,Jonas Wildberger,Jakob Macke,Isobel M. Romero-Shaw,Bernhard Schölkopf

2024-08-27

Abstract:Binary black holes (BBHs) in eccentric orbits produce distinct modulations the emitted gravitational waves (GWs). The measurement of orbital eccentricity can provide robust evidence for dynamical binary formation channels. We analyze 57 GW events from the first, second and third observing runs of the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) Collaboration using a multipolar aligned-spin inspiral-merger-ringdown waveform model with two eccentric parameters: eccentricity and relativistic anomaly. This is made computationally feasible with the machine-learning code DINGO which accelerates inference by 2-3 orders of magnitude compared to traditional inference. First, we find eccentric aligned-spin versus quasi-circular aligned-spin $\log_{10}$ Bayes factors of 1.84 to 4.75 (depending on the glitch mitigation) for GW200129, 3.0 for GW190701 and 1.77 for GW200208_22. We measure $e_{\text{gw}, 10Hz}$ to be $0.27_{-0.12}^{+0.10}$ to $0.17_{-0.13}^{+0.14}$ for GW200129, $0.35_{-0.11}^{+0.32}$ for GW190701 and $0.35_{-0.21}^{+0.18}$ for GW200208_22. Second, we find $\log_{10}$ Bayes factors between the eccentric aligned-spin versus quasi-circular precessing-spin hypothesis between 1.43 and 4.92 for GW200129, 2.61 for GW190701 and 1.23 for GW200208_22. Third, our analysis does not show evidence for eccentricity in GW190521, which has an eccentric aligned-spin against quasi-circular aligned-spin $\log_{10}$ Bayes factor of 0.04. Fourth, we estimate that if we neglect the spin-precession and use an astrophysical prior, the probability of one out of the 57 events being eccentric is greater than 99.5% or $(100 - 8.4 \times 10^{-4})$% (depending on the glitch mitigation). Fifth, we study the impact on parameter estimation when neglecting either eccentricity or higher modes in eccentric models. These results underscore the importance of including eccentric parameters in the characterization of BBHs for GW detectors.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Whether there is orbital eccentricity in the binary black hole system before merger**. Specifically, the authors explored this problem by analyzing 57 gravitational - wave events recorded by the LIGO - Virgo - KAGRA (LVK) collaboration during the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd observing runs, using the multipole - aligned - spin - inspiral - merger - ringdown model with two eccentricity parameters (eccentricity and relativistic anomaly). The main objectives of the study are:

1. **Verify the orbital eccentricity of the binary black hole system**: By comparing the Bayes factors of the eccentric - aligned - spin model and the quasi - circular - aligned - spin model, determine whether certain gravitational - wave events support the eccentric - orbit hypothesis more.
2. **Evaluate the influence of eccentric orbits**: Study the influence of ignoring eccentric orbits or high - order modes in parameter estimation to evaluate the potential biases of these factors on the measurement of the characteristics of the binary black hole system.
3. **Estimate the proportion of eccentric binary black holes**: Combine astrophysical prior knowledge and gravitational - wave data to estimate the proportion of eccentric binary black holes in the observed binary black hole population.

Through these analyses, the paper aims to provide important clues about the formation mechanism of binary black holes, especially to distinguish between the dynamical formation channel and the isolated binary star evolution channel. The existence of eccentric orbits can be a reliable indicator of the dynamical formation channel because isolated binary stars usually become quasi - circular before entering the LVK frequency band. Therefore, studying eccentric orbits helps to understand the formation and evolution processes of binary black holes.