Abstract:The Jupiter-Saturn chaotic excitation (JSCE) scenario proposes that the protoplanetary disk was dynamically excited and depleted beyond ~1-1.5 au in a few Myr, offering a new and plausible explanation for several observed properties of the inner solar system. Here, we expanded our previous work by conducting a comprehensive analysis of 37 optimal terrestrial planet systems obtained in the context of the JSCE scenario. Each optimal system harbored exactly four terrestrial planets analogs to Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars. We further investigated water delivery, feeding zones, and accretion history for the planet analogs, which allowed us to better constrain the water distribution in the disk. The main findings of this work are as follows: 1) the formation of four terrestrial planets with orbits and masses similar to those observed in our solar system in most of our sample, as evidenced by the dynamically colder and hotter orbits of Venus-Earth and Mercury-Mars analogs, and the high success rates of similar mutual orbital separations (~40-85%) and mass ratios of the planets (~70-90%) among the 37 systems; and 2) water was delivered to all terrestrial planets during their formation through the accretion of water-bearing disk objects from beyond ~1-1.5 au. The achievement of Earth's estimated bulk water content required the disk to contain sufficient water mass distributed within those objects initially. This requirement implies that Mercury, Venus, and Mars acquired water similar to the amount on Earth during their formation. Several of our planet analogs also matched additional constraints, such as the timing of Moon formation by a giant impact, Earth's late accretion mass and composition, and Mars's formation timescale.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper discusses the formation process of the four terrestrial planets in the solar system - Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars - and how they acquired water. The study is based on the "Jupiter-Saturn Chaotic Excitation" (JSCE) scenario, which suggests that within a few million years, the primordial planetary disk is dynamically excited and depleted outside of 1 to 1.5 astronomical units (au), providing a new perspective to explain the characteristics of the inner solar system.
The study analyzed 37 best-fit terrestrial planet systems formed under the JSCE scenario, each of which includes orbits and masses similar to the four planets in our solar system. The study found that all the planets obtained a considerable amount of water from objects beyond 1 au during the formation process. The majority of Earth's carbonaceous material likely originated from within 2 au, and the mass, eccentricity, inclination, and distance from Earth of the simulated Mars match well.
Furthermore, the paper emphasizes the interrelationship in the formation of Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars, and their orbits, masses, and water distribution are crucial for understanding the early solar system. While previous studies have been able to form planets similar to Earth and Venus, the formation of low-mass planets like Mars and Mercury remains a challenge, especially in simultaneously satisfying the constraints of orbit and mass.
The study further explores the accretion history of planets, the source of water, and the timing of moon formation to better constrain the distribution of water in the primordial planetary disk. The paper points out that a successful model should explain the formation of all four planets, including the small mass and relatively excited orbits of Mercury and its distance from Venus.
In conclusion, the aim of this paper, using the JSCE scenario, is to address the question of how to explain the formation of the four terrestrial planets, particularly their orbital characteristics, mass, source of water, and mutual interactions, while complying with existing observational data.