Urban highways are barriers to social ties

Luca Maria Aiello,Anastassia Vybornova,Sándor Juhász,Michael Szell,Eszter Bokányi

2024-04-18

Abstract:Urban highways are common, especially in the US, making cities more car-centric. They promise the annihilation of distance but obstruct pedestrian mobility, thus playing a key role in limiting social interactions locally. Although this limiting role is widely acknowledged in urban studies, the quantitative relationship between urban highways and social ties is barely tested. Here we define a Barrier Score that relates massive, geolocated online social network data to highways in the 50 largest US cities. At the unprecedented granularity of individual social ties, we show that urban highways are associated with decreased social connectivity. This barrier effect is especially strong for short distances and consistent with historical cases of highways that were built to purposefully disrupt or isolate Black neighborhoods. By combining spatial infrastructure with social tie data, our method adds a new dimension to demographic studies of social segregation. Our study can inform reparative planning for an evidence-based reduction of spatial inequality, and more generally, support a better integration of the social fabric in urban planning.

Physics and Society,Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses how urban highways have become barriers to social connections. The research indicates that although urban highways play a role in reducing geographical distances, they also hinder pedestrian movement, thereby limiting local social interaction. Despite widespread recognition of this issue in the field of urban planning, there have been few tests quantifying the relationship between urban highways and social connections.

The researchers proposed a measure called "barrier score" which quantifies the impact of highways on social connectivity by comparing online social network data for large geolocated populations (using Twitter users from the 50 largest cities in the United States as an example) with the presence of highways in these cities. The results show a decrease in social connectivity associated with urban highways, particularly noticeable at shorter distances. Over time, this impact may exacerbate racial segregation.

The paper also reviews several historical highways associated with racial segregation and finds that high "barrier scores" in proximity to these highways may reflect long-term effects of infrastructure on society from decades ago. These findings have important implications for evidence-based urban revitalization planning, reducing spatial inequalities, and better integrating social structures into urban planning.

Overall, the paper aims to address the quantification of the negative impact of urban highways on social interaction and provide policymakers with the basis for targeted interventions to reconnect urban communities and reduce spatial inequalities caused by urban planning.