FRESCO: The Paschen-$α$ Star Forming Sequence at Cosmic Noon

Chloe Neufeld,Pieter van Dokkum,Yasmeen Asali,Alba Covelo-Paz,Joel Leja,Jamie Lin,Jorryt Matthee,Pascal A. Oesch,Naveen A. Reddy,Irene Shivaei,Katherine E. Whitaker,Stijn Wuyts,Gabriel Brammer,Danilo Marchesini,Michael V. Maseda,Rohan P. Naidu,Erica J. Nelson,Anna Velichko,Andrea Weibel,Mengyuan Xiao

2024-07-10

Abstract:We present results from the JWST First Reionization Epoch Spectroscopically Complete Observations survey (FRESCO) on the star forming sequence of galaxies at $1.0<z<1.7$, around the peak of the cosmic star formation history. Star formation rates (SFRs) are measured from the redshifted, nearly dust-insensitive Paschen-$\alpha$ emission line, and stellar mass measurements include the F444W (4.4 $\mu$m; rest-frame H) band. We find SFRs of galaxies with $M*>9.5 M_\odot$ that are lower than found in many earlier studies by up to 0.6 dex, but in good agreement with recent results obtained with the Prospector fitting framework. The difference log(SFR(Pa$\alpha$)-SFR(Prospector)) is -0.09 $\pm$ 0.04 dex at $10^{10-11} M_\odot$. We also measure the empirical relation between Paschen-$\alpha$ luminosity and rest-frame H band magnitude and find that the scatter is only 0.04 dex lower than that of the SFR-M* relation and is much lower than the systematic differences among relations in the literature due to various methods of converting observed measurements to physical properties. We additionally identify examples of sources -- that, with standard cutoffs via the UVJ diagram, would be deemed quiescent -- with significant, typically extended, Paschen-$\alpha$ emission. Our results may be indicative of the potential unification of methods used to derive the star forming sequence with careful selection of star forming galaxies and independent star formation rate and stellar mass indicators.

Astrophysics of Galaxies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper mainly discusses the star formation sequence of galaxies during the cosmic noon period (approximately 1.0 < z < 1.7), that is, the relationship between the star formation rate (SFR) and the stellar mass (M*) of galaxies. The study used the FRESCO observation data from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to measure the dust-corrected, post-redshifted Paα emission line to determine the star formation rate, and combined it with the 4.4 micron data to estimate the stellar mass.

The research found that for galaxies with stellar masses greater than 10^9.5 solar masses, their SFR was 0.6 dex lower than previously estimated in many studies, but consistent with the results obtained using the Prospector framework. In addition, they measured the relationship between Paα luminosity and near-infrared H-band and found that it had lower dispersion than the SFR-M* relation and less systematic differences.

The paper also points out that the use of the standard UVJ diagram to select star-forming galaxies may have limitations, as some sources classified as "quiescent" actually exhibit significant Paα emission, indicating ongoing star formation activity. These results may imply the potential to unify different methods for determining the star formation sequence and the need for careful selection of star-forming galaxy samples as well as independent SFR and stellar mass indicators.

The researchers used various methods to infer the star formation rate and stellar mass, which may affect the measurement of the star formation sequence. For example, using UV continuum, infrared emission lines, or spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting across the entire wavelength range. As redshift increases, the normalization of the star formation sequence increases, indicating faster gas accretion in the early universe. At the same time, the slope of the sequence varies within different mass ranges, which may be related to galaxy evolution processes such as black hole feedback and the availability of cold gas reservoirs.

In summary, this paper aims to address how to more accurately measure and understand the star formation rate-stellar mass relation of star-forming galaxies during the cosmic noon period, as well as how the systematic differences of various methods affect the description of this relation.