Two-time quantities as elements of physical reality

Lucas Maquedano,Alexandre D. Ribeiro,Ana C. S. Costa,Renato M. Angelo

2024-04-17

Abstract:In recent years, time correlators have received renewed attention, especially under the guise of identifiers of nonclassical correlations. However, the physical interpretation of these objects, and more generally of multi-times variables, remains ambiguous, which may be one of the reasons why they are so difficult to measure. In this work, we introduce and advance the perspective that a two-time correlator should actually be regarded as an average involving a novel single physical observable, one that cannot be rephrased in terms of the primitive ones, according to quantum principles. In particular, we provide examples showing that the presumed constituents of a two-time correlator and the proposed two-time operator itself cannot be simultaneous elements of the physical reality.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the significance of two-time quantities in physics, especially as components of physical reality. Traditionally, physical quantities are considered to have definite values independent of observers at any given moment, but quantum mechanics challenges this view by not allowing simultaneous determinism for properties like position and momentum, thus rejecting determinism. The paper points out that two-time correlators have been studied in the description of nonclassical correlations, but their physical interpretation remains vague.

The authors propose that two-time correlators should not be regarded as mere composites of fundamental physical quantities, but as new quantum concepts with independent physical meanings. They argue this by introducing criteria of reality and quantifiers of correlation, showing that two-time operators can be real while their constituents are not. The paper demonstrates through concrete examples how two-time quantities cannot be accessed directly through traditional two-point measurement protocols within the framework of quantum mechanics, as quantum measurements always have invasiveness.

The paper also discusses the Leggett-Garg inequalities and the concept of macrorealism, violations of which suggest that the assumption of determinate values for macroscopic objects at all times is incompatible with quantum mechanics. The authors further develop a new quantum formulation, considering two-time operators as "nonlocal time physical quantities," and study how they can be independent elements of reality even if their constituents may not be.

The paper concludes with an example concerning the torque acting on a spin-1/2 particle in a magnetic field, illustrating that two-time quantities (in this case, torque) can be elements of reality while their components (such as angular momentum components) may not be. Using measures of reality, the authors demonstrate that in certain circumstances, two-time operators cannot coexist as real elements with single-time operators.

In summary, the paper aims to address the status of multiple time quantities in quantum mechanics, proposing a new understanding that could have implications for experimental tests of time-correlated functions.