Derivatives of Risk Measures

Battulga Gankhuu

2024-08-13

Abstract:This paper provides the first and second order derivatives of any risk measures, including VaR and ES for continuous and discrete portfolio loss random variable variables. Also, we give asymptotic results of the first and second order conditional moments for heavy-tailed portfolio loss random variable.

Risk Management

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Conditional Tail-Related Risk Estimation Using Composite Asymmetric Least Squares and Empirical Likelihood

Sheng Wu,Yi Zhang,Jun Zhao,Liming Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.1807.01666

2018-01-01

Abstract:In this article, by using composite asymmetric least squares (CALS) and empirical likelihood, we propose a two-step procedure to estimate the conditional value at risk (VaR) and conditional expected shortfall (ES) for the GARCH series. First, we perform asymmetric least square regressions at several significance levels to model the volatility structure and separate it from the innovation process in the GARCH model. Note that expectile can serve as a bond to make up the gap from VaR estimation to ES estimation because there exists a bijective mapping from expectiles to specific quantile, and ES can be induced by expectile through a simple formula. Then, we introduce the empirical likelihood method to determine the relation above; this method is data-driven and distribution-free. Theoretical studies guarantee the asymptotic properties, such as consistency and the asymptotic normal distribution of the estimator obtained by our proposed method. A Monte Carlo experiment and an empirical application are conducted to evaluate the performance of the proposed method. The results indicate that our proposed estimation method is competitive with some alternative existing tail-related risk estimation methods.
Ruin probabilities of a two-dimensional risk model with dependent risks of heavy tail

xinmei shen,yi zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spl.2013.03.029

IF: 0.718

2013-01-01

Statistics & Probability Letters

Abstract:This paper considers a two-dimensional discrete time risk model with constant interest rates, and individual net losses in ERV(−α,−β), the class of extended regular variations with indices 0<α≤β<∞. Some asymptotic results for both finite-time and infinite-time ruin probabilities under two types of ruin times are established. The two components of net losses are allowed to be generally dependent.
Risk concentration of aggregated dependent risks: The second-order properties

Bin Tong,Chongfeng Wu,Weidong Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.insmatheco.2011.11.002

2012-01-01

Insurance: Mathematics and Economics

Abstract:Under the current regulatory guidelines for banks and insurance companies, the quantification of diversification benefits due to risk aggregation plays a prominent role. In this paper we establish second-order approximation of risk concentration associated with a random vector X:=(X1,X2,…,Xd) in terms of Value at Risk (VaR) within the methodological framework of second-order regular variation and the theory of Archimedean copula. Moreover, we find that the rate of convergence of the first-order approximation of risk concentration depends on the the interplay between the tail behavior of the marginal loss random variables and their dependence structure. Specifically, we find that the rate of convergence is determined by either the second-order parameter (ρ1) of Archimedean copula generator or the second-order parameter (ρ) of the tail margins, leading to either the so-called dependence dominated case or margin dominated case.
Value-at-Risk- and Expectile-based Systemic Risk Measures and Second-order Asymptotics: With Applications to Diversification

Bingzhen Geng,Yang Liu,Yimiao Zhao

2024-04-28

Abstract:The systemic risk measure plays a crucial role in analyzing individual losses conditioned on extreme system-wide disasters. In this paper, we provide a unified asymptotic treatment for systemic risk measures. First, we classify them into two families of Value-at-Risk- (VaR-) and expectile-based systemic risk measures. While VaR has been extensively studied, in the latter family, we propose two new systemic risk measures named the Individual Conditional Expectile (ICE) and the Systemic Individual Conditional Expectile (SICE), as alternatives to Marginal Expected Shortfall (MES) and Systemic Expected Shortfall (SES). Second, to characterize general mutually dependent and heavy-tailed risks, we adopt a modeling framework where the system, represented by a vector of random loss variables, follows a multivariate Sarmanov distribution with a common marginal exhibiting second-order regular variation. Third, we provide second-order asymptotic results for both families of systemic risk measures. This analytical framework offers a more accurate estimate compared to traditional first-order asymptotics. Through numerical and analytical examples, we demonstrate the superiority of second-order asymptotics in accurately assessing systemic risk. Further, we conduct a comprehensive comparison between VaR-based and expectile-based systemic risk measures. Expectile-based measures output higher risk evaluation than VaR-based ones, emphasizing the former's potential advantages in reporting extreme events and tail risk. As a financial application, we use the asymptotic treatment to discuss the diversification benefits associated with systemic risk measures. The expectile-based diversification benefits consistently deduce an underestimation and suggest a conservative approximation, while the VaR-based diversification benefits consistently deduce an overestimation and suggest behaving optimistically.

Risk Management
An Analysis of Risk Measures

Guojun Wu,Zhijie Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21314/jor.2002.067

2002-01-01

The Journal of Risk

Abstract:Several recent articles on risk management indicate that a quantile measure of losses such as value-at-risk may not contain enough, or the right, information for risk managers. This paper presents a comprehensive empirical analysis of a set of left-tail measures (LTMs): the mean and standard deviation of a loss larger than the VAR (MLL and SDLL) and the VAR. We investigate the empirical dynamics of the LTMs. We present a robust and unified framework, the Arch quantile regression approach, in estimating the LTMs. Our Monte Carlo simulation shows that the VAR is appropriate for risk management when returns follow Gaussian processes, but the MLL strategy and strategies accounting for the SDLL are useful in reducing the risk of large losses under non-normal distributions and when there are jumps in asset prices.
Risk Measures Based on Benchmark Loss Distributions

Valeria Bignozzi,Matteo Burzoni,Cosimo Munari

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3088423

2017-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We introduce a class of quantile-based risk measures that generalize Value at Risk (VaR) and, likewise Expected Shortfall (ES), take into account both the frequency and the severity of losses. Under VaR a single confidence level is assigned regardless of the size of potential losses. We allow for a range of confidence levels that depend on the loss magnitude. The key ingredient is a benchmark loss distribution (BLD), i.e.~a function that associates to each potential loss a maximal acceptable probability of occurrence. The corresponding risk measure, called Loss VaR (LVaR), determines the minimal capital injection that is required to align the loss distribution of a risky position to the target BLD. By design, one has full flexibility in the choice of the BLD profile and, therefore, in the range of relevant quantiles. Special attention is given to piecewise constant functions and to tail distributions of benchmark random losses, in which case the acceptability condition imposed by the BLD boils down to first-order stochastic dominance. We provide a comprehensive study of the main finance theoretical and statistical properties of LVaR with a focus on their comparison with VaR and ES. Merits and drawbacks are discussed and applications to capital adequacy, portfolio risk management and catastrophic risk are presented.
Derivative Preserving Conditions in Conditional Expectation Operator

Battulga Gankhuu

2024-08-13

Abstract:In this paper, we consider conditions that a higher order derivative preserve in conditional expectation operator for a generic nonlinear random variable. Also, the paper introduces higher order derivatives of the Expected Shortfall for a generic nonlinear portfolio loss random variable.

Probability
Asymptotic Properties of Generalized Shortfall Risk Measures for Heavy-tailed Risks

Tiantian Mao,Gilles Stupfler,Fan Yang

2024-11-12

Abstract:We study a general risk measure called the generalized shortfall risk measure, which was first introduced in Mao and Cai (2018). It is proposed under the rank-dependent expected utility framework, or equivalently induced from the cumulative prospect theory. This risk measure can be flexibly designed to capture the decision maker's behavior toward risks and wealth when measuring risk. In this paper, we derive the first- and second-order asymptotic expansions for the generalized shortfall risk measure. Our asymptotic results can be viewed as unifying theory for, among others, distortion risk measures and utility-based shortfall risk measures. They also provide a blueprint for the estimation of these measures at extreme levels, and we illustrate this principle by constructing and studying a quantile-based estimator in a special case. The accuracy of the asymptotic expansions and of the estimator is assessed on several numerical examples.

Risk Management
Worst-Case Range Value-at-Risk with Partial Information

Lujun Li,Hui Shao,Ruodu Wang,Jingping Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1137/17m1126138

2018-01-01

SIAM Journal on Financial Mathematics

Abstract:In this paper, we study the worst-case scenarios of a general class of risk measures, the range value-at-risk (RVaR), in single and aggregate risk models with given mean and variance, as well as symmetry and/or unimodality of each risk. For different types of partial information settings, sharp bounds for RVaR are obtained for single and aggregate risk models, together with the corresponding worst-case scenarios of marginal risks and the corresponding copula functions (dependence structure) among them. Different from the existing literature, the sharp bounds under different partial information settings in this paper are obtained via a unified method combining convex order and the recently developed notion of joint mixability. As particular cases, bounds for value-at-risk and tail value-at-risk are derived directly. Numerical examples are also provided to illustrate our results.
Diversification quotients based on VaR and ES

Xia Han,Liyuan Lin,Ruodu Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.03517

2023-05-11

Abstract:The diversification quotient (DQ) is recently introduced for quantifying the degree of diversification of a stochastic portfolio model. It has an axiomatic foundation and can be defined through a parametric class of risk measures. Since the Value-at-Risk (VaR) and the Expected Shortfall (ES) are the most prominent risk measures widely used in both banking and insurance, we investigate DQ constructed from VaR and ES in this paper. In particular, for the popular models of elliptical and multivariate regular varying (MRV) distributions, explicit formulas are available. The portfolio optimization problems for the elliptical and MRV models are also studied. Our results further reveal favourable features of DQ, both theoretically and practically, compared to traditional diversification indices based on a single risk measure.

Risk Management
Second-order Expansions of the Risk Concentration Based on CTE

Tiantian Mao,Wenhua Lv,Taizhong Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.insmatheco.2012.07.002

2012-01-01

Abstract:The quantification of diversification benefits due to risk aggregation has received more attention in the recent literature. In this paper, we establish second-order expansions of the risk concentration based on the risk measure of conditional tail expectation for a portfolio of n independent and identically distributed loss random variables. The key tools are the theory of second-order regular variation and the theory of second-order subexponentiality. Some examples are given.
Estimating value at risk and conditional tail expectation for extreme and aggregate risks

Suman Thapa,Yiqiang Q. Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2101.12402

2021-01-29

Risk Management

Abstract:In this paper, we investigate risk measures such as value at risk (VaR) and the conditional tail expectation (CTE) of the extreme (maximum and minimum) and the aggregate (total) of two dependent risks. In finance, insurance and the other fields, when people invest their money in two or more dependent or independent markets, it is very important to know the extreme and total risk before the investment. To find these risk measures for dependent cases is quite challenging, which has not been reported in the literature to the best of our knowledge. We use the FGM copula for modelling the dependence as it is relatively simple for computational purposes and has empirical successes. The marginal of the risks are considered as exponential and pareto, separately, for the case of extreme risk and as exponential for the case of the total risk. The effect of the degree of dependency on the VaR and CTE of the extreme and total risks is analyzed. We also make comparisons for the dependent and independent risks. Moreover, we propose a new risk measure called median of tail (MoT) and investigate MoT for the extreme and aggregate dependent risks.
Adjusted Rényi Entropic Value-at-Risk

Zhenfeng Zou,Qinyu Wu,Zichao Xia,Taizhong Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2022.08.028

IF: 6.4

2023-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:Entropy is a measure of self information or uncertainty. Using different concepts of entropy, we may get different risk measures by dual representation. In this paper, we introduce and study the main properties of a class of convex risk measures, called as adjusted Renyi entropic Value-at-Risk (VaR). The adjusted risk measure quantifies risk as the minimum amount of capital that has to be raised and injected into a financial position to ensure that its Renyi entropic-VaR does not exceed a pre-specified threshold for every probability level. When p is an element of [1 , infinity), the adjusted Renyi entropic-VaR of order p is intimately linked to the (p + 1)-increasing convex order by choosing the risk threshold to be the Renyi entropic-VaR of a benchmark random loss.(c) 2022 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
ASYMPTOTIC EXPANSIONS OF GENERALIZED QUANTILES AND EXPECTILES FOR EXTREME RISKS

tiantian mao,k w ng,taizhong hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0269964815000017

2015-01-01

Probability in the Engineering and Informational Sciences

Abstract:Generalized quantiles of a random variable were defined as the minimizers of a general asymmetric loss function, which include quantiles, expectiles and M-quantiles as their special cases. Expectiles have been suggested as potentially better alternatives to both Value-at-Risk and expected shortfall risk measures. In this paper, we first establish the first-order expansions of generalized quantiles for extreme risks as the confidence level alpha up arrow 1, and then investigate the first-order and/or second-order expansions of expectiles of an extreme risk as alpha up arrow 1 according to the underlying distribution belonging to the max-domain of attraction of the Frechet, Weibull, and Gumbel distributions, respectively. Examples are also presented to examine whether and how much the first-order expansions have been improved by the second-order expansions.
Efficient Risk Measures Calculations for Generalized CreditRisk+ Models

Yue Kuen Kwok

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3680659

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Numerical calculations of risk measures in credit risk models amount to evaluation of various forms of tail expectations of portfolio loss distribution. Though the moment generating function of the loss distribution in CreditRisk+ model is available in analytic closed form, efficient, accurate and reliable computation of risk measures (VaR and Expected Shortfall) and risk contributions for the CreditRisk+ model pose technical challenge. We propose various numerical algorithms for risk measures and risk contributions calculations of the enhanced CreditRisk+ model under the common background vector framework using the Johnson curve fitting method, saddle-point approximation method, curve fitting method, importance sampling in Monte Carlo simulation and check function formulation. Our numerical studies on stylized credit portfolios and benchmark industrial credit portfolios reveal that the Johnson curve fitting approach works very well for credit portfolios with a large number of obligors, demonstrating high level of numerical reliability and computational efficiency. The importance sampling in Monte Carlo simulation methods are easy to implement, but they compete less favorably in accuracy and reliability with other numerical algorithms. The less commonly used check function formulation is limited to risk measures calculations. It competes favorably in accuracy and reliability, but an external industrial optimization software is required.

English Else
RISK MEASURES DERIVED FROM A REGULATOR'S PERSPECTIVE ON THE REGULATORY CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS FOR INSURERS

Jun Cai,Tiantian Mao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/asb.2020.22

2020-01-01

Astin Bulletin

Abstract:In this study, we propose new risk measures from a regulator's perspective on the regulatory capital requirements. The proposed risk measures possess many desired properties, including monotonicity, translation-invariance, positive homogeneity, subadditivity, nonnegative loading, and stop-loss order preserving. The new risk measures not only generalize the existing, well-known risk measures in the literature, including the Dutch, tail value-at-risk (TVaR), and expectile measures, but also provide new approaches to generate feasible and practical coherent risk measures. As examples of the new risk measures, TVaR-type generalized expectiles are investigated in detail. In particular, we present the dual and Kusuoka representations of the TVaR-type generalized expectiles and discuss their robustness with respect to the Wasserstein distance.
Second-order Properties of the Haezendonck–Goovaerts Risk Measure for Extreme Risks

Tiantian Mao,Taizhong Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.insmatheco.2012.06.003

2012-01-01

Abstract:The Haezendonck–Goovaerts risk measure is based on the premium calculation principle induced by an Orlicz norm, which is defined via an increasing and convex Young function and a parameter q∈(0,1) representing the confidence level. In this paper, we first reestablish the first-order expansions of the Haezendonck–Goovaerts risk measure for extreme risks with a power Young function in Tang and Yang (2012) in terms of the tail quantile function. Second, we are interested in the calculation of the second-order expansions of the Haezendonck–Goovaerts risk measure as q↑1. We only consider the case in which the risk variable belongs to the max-domain of attraction of an extreme value distribution.
Second-order properties of risk concentrations without the condition of asymptotic smoothness

Tiantian Mao,Taizhong Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10687-012-0164-z

2013-01-01

Extremes

Abstract:For the purpose of risk management, the quantification of diversification benefits due to risk aggregation has received more attention in the recent literature. Consider a portfolio of n independent and identically distributed loss random variables with a common survival function F possessing the property of second-order regular variation. Under the additional assumption that F is asymptotically smooth, Degen et al. (Insur Math Econ 46:541–546, 2010 ) and Mao et al. (Insur Math Econ 51:449–456, 2012 ) derived second-order approximations of the risk concentrations based on the risk measures of Value-at-Risk and conditional tail expectation, respectively. In this paper, we remove the assumption of the asymptotic smoothness, and reestablish the second-order approximations of these two risk concentrations.
Measures of Model Risk for Continuous-Time Finance Models

Emese Lazar,Shuyuan Qi,Radu Tunaru

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jjfinec/nbae001

IF: 3.976

2024-02-02

Journal of Financial Econometrics

Abstract:Abstract Measuring model risk is required by regulators in financial and insurance markets. We separate model risk into parameter estimation risk (PER) and model specification risk (MSR), and we propose expected shortfall type model risk measures applied to Lévy jump, affine jump-diffusion, and multifactor models. We investigate the impact of PER and MSR on the models’ ability to capture the joint dynamics of stock and option prices. Using Markov chain Monte Carlo techniques, we implement two methodologies to estimate parameters under the risk-neutral probability measure and the real-world probability measure jointly.

economics,business, finance
Making heads or tails of systemic risk measures

Aleksy Leeuwenkamp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2206.02582

2023-04-26

Abstract:This paper shows that the CoVaR,$\Delta$-CoVaR,CoES,$\Delta$-CoES and MES systemic risk measures can be represented in terms of the univariate risk measure evaluated at a quantile determined by the copula. The result is applied to derive empirically relevant properties of these measures concerning their sensitivity to power-law tails, outliers and their properties under aggregation. Furthermore, a novel empirical estimator for the CoES is proposed. The power-law result is applied to derive a novel empirical estimator for the power-law coefficient which depends on $\Delta\text{-CoVaR}/\Delta\text{-CoES}$. To show empirical performance simulations and an application of the methods to a large dataset of financial institutions are used. This paper finds that the MES is not suitable for measuring extreme risks. Also, the ES-based measures are more sensitive to power-law tails and large losses. This makes these measures more useful for measuring network risk but less so for systemic risk. The robustness analysis also shows that all $\Delta$ measures can underestimate due to the occurrence of intermediate losses. Lastly, it is found that the power-law tail coefficient estimator can be used as an early-warning indicator of systemic risk.

Risk Management,General Economics,General Finance

Derivatives of Risk Measures

Conditional Tail-Related Risk Estimation Using Composite Asymmetric Least Squares and Empirical Likelihood

Ruin probabilities of a two-dimensional risk model with dependent risks of heavy tail

Risk concentration of aggregated dependent risks: The second-order properties

Value-at-Risk- and Expectile-based Systemic Risk Measures and Second-order Asymptotics: With Applications to Diversification

An Analysis of Risk Measures

Risk Measures Based on Benchmark Loss Distributions

Derivative Preserving Conditions in Conditional Expectation Operator

Asymptotic Properties of Generalized Shortfall Risk Measures for Heavy-tailed Risks

Worst-Case Range Value-at-Risk with Partial Information

Diversification quotients based on VaR and ES

Second-order Expansions of the Risk Concentration Based on CTE

Estimating value at risk and conditional tail expectation for extreme and aggregate risks

Adjusted Rényi Entropic Value-at-Risk

ASYMPTOTIC EXPANSIONS OF GENERALIZED QUANTILES AND EXPECTILES FOR EXTREME RISKS

Efficient Risk Measures Calculations for Generalized CreditRisk+ Models

RISK MEASURES DERIVED FROM A REGULATOR'S PERSPECTIVE ON THE REGULATORY CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS FOR INSURERS

Second-order Properties of the Haezendonck–Goovaerts Risk Measure for Extreme Risks

Second-order properties of risk concentrations without the condition of asymptotic smoothness

Measures of Model Risk for Continuous-Time Finance Models

Making heads or tails of systemic risk measures