Is Doublet-Triplet Splitting Necessary?

Ilja Doršner,Shaikh Saad
2024-10-17
Abstract:We demonstrate that it is not necessary to substantially break the mass degeneracy between the Standard Model Higgs boson doublet and the corresponding scalar leptoquark, where these two fields comprise a single five-dimensional $SU(5)$ representation. More precisely, we show that the experimental data on partial proton decay lifetimes cannot place any meaningful bound on the mass of the scalar leptoquark, a.k.a. the color triplet, if one includes effects of higher-dimensional operators within the Georgi-Glashow model. We also point out that the complete suppression of proton decay via the scalar leptoquark mediation is compatible with the partial suppression of the gauge mediated two-body proton decay signatures. Finally, we derive a proper limit on the cutoff scale of the aforementioned higher-dimensional operators and outline how this scenario could be tested.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether it is necessary to distinguish the Standard Model Higgs doublet from the corresponding scalar leptoquark, i.e., the color triplet, by introducing significant mass splitting within the framework of the SU(5) grand unified theory. Specifically, the author explores whether the experimental data on the partial proton decay lifetimes can provide meaningful constraints on the mass of the color triplet when considering the effects of high - dimensional operators. ### Background In the Georgi - Glashow model, a notable feature is the need to introduce a huge mass splitting between two multiplets in the same five - dimensional scalar representation \(5_H\). One multiplet is the Higgs doublet \(D\) of the Standard Model (SM), and the other is the color triplet \(T\) that causes proton decay. Since the Higgs boson is observed to be light, and the scalar leptoquark that mediates proton decay should be very heavy, it is necessary to strongly break the mass degeneracy between them. This problem is known as the Doublet - Triplet splitting problem. ### Main problems 1. **Whether significant mass splitting is required**: The paper explores whether significant mass splitting is really required to distinguish the Higgs doublet from the color triplet when considering the effects of high - dimensional operators. 2. **Constraints from experimental data**: The author studies whether the experimental data on the partial proton decay lifetimes can provide meaningful constraints on the mass of the color triplet. ### Solutions The author shows that significant mass splitting is not required through the following methods: - **Introduction of high - dimensional operators**: By introducing high - dimensional operators, the proton decay signal mediated by the scalar leptoquark can be completely suppressed without affecting the mechanism for generating the Standard Model charged fermion masses. - **Partial and complete suppression**: The author also shows that complete suppression of the scalar - mediated proton decay signal is compatible with partial suppression of the gauge - mediated two - body proton decay signal. - **Upper limit of the cutoff scale**: The author derives an accurate upper limit for determining the cutoff scale \(\Lambda\) associated with high - dimensional operators if partial suppression of the gauge - mediated two - body proton decay signal, complete suppression of the scalar - mediated proton decay, or both are implemented. ### Conclusions The main conclusion of the paper is that the experimental data on the partial proton decay lifetimes cannot provide meaningful constraints on the mass of the color triplet, provided that the effects of high - dimensional operators are considered. This result applies to supersymmetric and non - supersymmetric SU(5) frameworks that use five - dimensional operators to generate Standard Model charged fermion masses. This undermines the basic premise of implementing doublet - triplet mass splitting in such models.